AC - asian NC - Disclosure Identity Theory T-FW Cap K PP Counter ROTB Policy 1AR - all 2NR - all 2AR - all
NSDA Nats
1
Opponent: 824 | Judge: many
AC - Stock NC - Korsgaard Voluntarism CP
NSDA Nats
4
Opponent: numbers | Judge: multiple
AC - who knows NC - Mill trix Voluntarism
NSDA Nats
5
Opponent: numbers | Judge: dont remember
AC - Stock NC - Mills trix Voluntarism
VBI PHL Online
4
Opponent: Griffin Ferzan | Judge: Silma Bathily
idfk
VBI PHL Online
Finals
Opponent: Sophie Pearo | Judge: panel
AC - Space Debris Asteroids Space Wars NC - T SOP Mining DA Reg CP Nukes CP 1AR - disp bad shell RVI on T Asteroids 1N - all climate change reg cp
VBI PHL Online
2
Opponent: Chloe Chun | Judge: Carlos Astacio
1AC - China Antartica NoKo 1N- SOP Sec K 'Mankind K' Mining DA
VBI PHL Online
5
Opponent: Lauren Stoffel | Judge: Quentin Clark
AC - Baudrillard 1N - SOP Cap K Author Indicts
To modify or delete round reports, edit the associated round.
Cites
Entry
Date
0 - Contact Info
Tournament: x | Round: Finals | Opponent: xX | Judge: x Email me @ lmokriski@solebury.org for whatever u need. Go for substance thx
9/7/21
0 - Navigation
Tournament: TOC | Round: Finals | Opponent: eren jaeger | Judge: mr peanutbutter SO = September October LD Topic ND = November December LD Topic JF = January February LD Topic
K = Kritik DA = Disadvantage CP = Counterplan PIC/K = Plan Inclusive Counterplan/Kritik T = Topicality TS = Theory Shells G = Generics
9/1/21
0 - PLEASE READ
Tournament: dont make me mad pls | Round: Finals | Opponent: x | Judge: xX pls put content warnings on all conversations of SA, Suicide, PTSD, Trauma, etc.
I will get very mad if u 1 pressure me to talk about my persona identity in a debate round 2 invalidate my existence or validity of my args based on my identity 3 Be racist, sexist, homophobic, transphobic, xenophobic, etc.
I will get pretty mad if u 1 read trix, or nondilineated spikes 2 read contradicting conditional advocacies 3 read more than 3 off theory shells 4 don't disclose
debate is supposed to be fun so I'd prefer if we keep it that way. I don't want to leave the round hating ppl, but sum of yall do this to win ballots instead of having fun
9/5/21
G - Disclosure
Tournament: Loyola | Round: 6 | Opponent: Strake Jesuit NW | Judge: Chaitra Pirisingula Interp The aff must disclose the AC doc 30 minutes before the rnd.
9/7/21
G - Identity Shell
Tournament: Loyola | Round: 6 | Opponent: Strake Jesuit NW | Judge: Chaitra Pirisingula Interp: Debaters must not ask other debaters to describe their ethnicity or any part of their personal identity for disclosure.
Presumption negates – infinite ways for something to be false but only one way for them to be true. Permissibility negates – if IPP isn't bad then its morally neutral and permissible.
The counter ROTJ is to vote for the better debater. The ROTB is whoever best argues for or against the policy implementation of the resolution.
2~ Inclusion – their model debate is great for X, but exclusionairy of everyone else. Regulating debate to focus on one group is inherently exclusionary, focusing on substance and policy solves.
3~ Solves the T-fw shell and its standards.
4~ Topics ed – tying our model of debate to the topic is key to it being good, topic eds key to education, ground, clash, fairness etc.
5~ Arg diversity – their model of debate creates a performative echo chamber where students just repeat prewritten k affs every two months, forgoing substantive clash, policy discussion, and topic ed.
6~ Our model of debate is a prereq to theirs, we can only read kritiks of policies and policy discussion, if it's happening.
7~ Ground – our model of debate includes theirs, but theirs precludes ours, as under policy analysis we can still have things like Ks, and Kritikal affs about the topic, but they never let us discuss policies.
9/7/21
G - T-fw
Tournament: Loyola | Round: 6 | Opponent: Strake Jesuit NW | Judge: Chaitra Pirisingula Interp: aff must only get offense off the desirability of the resolution.
The affs medical view of COVID understands life in its proximity to death, turning the living into undead zombies. Link work – COVID cards in 1st adv and inherency.
Till 21 ~Chris Till, Cost of Living, "Living under the medical gaze in a time of pandemics," February 10th, 2021, https://www.cost-ofliving.net/living-under-the-medical-gaze-in-a-time-of-pandemics/~~/ lm The "medical gaze" is a concept originally taken from Michel Foucault's 1963 book AND protect ourselves and others; lets hope we can soon let it retreat.
The affs narrative of global north-south health divide and desire for expanding Western medicine creates a Medical Gaze which objectifies Aboriginal bodies and continues colonialism and denies mutual recognition.
Bradley 16 ~Elain Bradley, Canadian Medical Education Journal, NCBI, PMC, US National Library of Medicine, National Institute of Health, "Changing perspectives: attempting to de-colonize the gaze of a Canadian medical student," December 5th, 2016, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5342885/~~/ lm In my final year of medical school, I undertook an elective focused on urban AND how can this translate into something that can be taught to medical students?
The aff's Medical Gaze reinforces racism, classism and neoliberal concepts of health.
Balcioglu 12 ~Zeynep Balcioglu, Zeynep Balcioglu is a doctoral candidate in the Department of Political Science at Northeastern University, specializing in public policy, E-International Relations, "The Medical Gaze Between the Doctor, the Patient, and the State," October 11th, 2012, https://www.e-ir.info/2012/10/11/the-medical-gaze-between-the-doctor-the-patient-and-the-state/~~/ lm When medicine becomes the only social language, the distinction between the doctor and the AND , the doctor and the state, and the patient and the state.
9/5/21
SO - Cap K vs Asian
Tournament: Loyola | Round: 6 | Opponent: Strake Jesuit NW | Judge: Chaitra Pirisingula The aff's single issue approach is revolution without revolution – that ruins our ability to resist global capitalism. Zizek 02 Slavoj Zizek, “Revolution at the Gates,” pg 296-302, 2002/ lm
Our identities are determined by political and economic consumption – capitalism makes the autonomous subject impossible. Blühdorn 6—Professor of Socioeconomics at Wirtschaftsuniversität Wien Ingolfur, “Self-Experience in the Theme Park of Radical Action? Social Movements and Political Articulation in the Late-Modern Condition,” European Journal of Social Theory, Vol. 9, No. 1, p. 23-42
That causes material violence which increases inequality, environmental destruction and causes extinction. Robinson 18 William I, professor of sociology, global studies and Latin American studies at the University of California at Santa Barbara. 2018. “Accumulation Crisis and Global Police State.”http:revolutionary-socialism.com/en/accumulation-crisis-and-global-police-state/
The alternative is to Join the Party – reject folk politics and focus on building dual power to resist capitalism and materially benefit oppressed peoples. Escalante 18 Alyson, philosophy at U of Oregon, 08/24/2018. “Against Electoralism, For Dual Power!” https://theforgenews.org/2018/08/24/against-electoralism-for-dual-power/ lm
Thus, the Counterplan – add a Health Impact Fund to incentivize Pharmaceuticals to voluntarily lower prices and increase access. This would add a complement to IPP rather than reducing it.
Pogge 10 ~Thomas Pogge, Thomas Winfried Menko Pogge is a German philosopher and is the Director of the Global Justice Program and Leitner Professor of Philosophy and International Affairs at Yale University. Cambridge University Press, "Incentives for Global Health: Patent Law and Access to Essential Medicines. The Health Impact Fund: Better Pharmaceutical Innovations at Much Lower Prices," 2010, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1431180~~/ lm
The exclusion of the poor by the existing patent regime requires reform. Given AND of new high-impact medicines without excluding the poor from its use.
That solves the aff by including the poor and increasing access while it's voluntary, and IPP remains unchanged.
Pogge 10 ~Thomas Pogge, Thomas Winfried Menko Pogge is a German philosopher and is the Director of the Global Justice Program and Leitner Professor of Philosophy and International Affairs at Yale University. Cambridge University Press, "Incentives for Global Health: Patent Law and Access to Essential Medicines. The Health Impact Fund: Better Pharmaceutical Innovations at Much Lower Prices," 2010, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1431180~~/ lm Let us recapitulate how the HIF would provide a full systemic solution to the seven AND these countries in order to enhance the impact of their HIFregistered medicines there.
Ethics starts with self-actualization, described as the capacity to abstract from one's particular conditions through embodying personality in the world and recognition from others. Thus, the standard is consistency with mutual recognition.
Wood 90 ~Allen W. Wood, Ruth Norman Halls Professor of Philosophy, Indiana University, "Hegel's Ethical Thought" Cambridge University Press, 1990, https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/hegels-ethical-thought/D409B1F04527F36C32227799D0B303E5~~/ lm If there is any hope for ethics as a branch of rational inquiry, it AND its satisfaction only in another self-consciousness" (PhG 1 175).
Now negate –
1~ Intellectual property protections are justified for enabling self-actualization.
Moore and Hinma 18 ~Moore, Adam and Ken Himma, "Intellectual Property", The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Winter 2018 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.), https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2018/entries/intellectual-property/~~/ lm Personality theorists such as Hegel maintain that individuals have moral claims to their own talents AND to adopt a more comprehensive system designed to promote progress and social utility.
2~ IPP is necessary for achieving mutual recognition through materializing the personality of the inventor in the market.
Hughes 88 ~Justin Hughes, Prior to joining Loyola in 2013, Professor Justin Hughes taught at Cardozo Law School where he served as director of Cardozo's Intellectual Property Program, 2004 through 2008, and founded the law school's Indie Film Clinic, the first of its kind, "The Philosophy of Intellectual Property," 77 Georgetown L.J. 287, 330-350 (1988), https://cyber.harvard.edu/IPCoop/88hugh2.html~~/ lm Not only does Hegel's personality theory pose no inherent objection to this kind of alienation AND is destroyed; when the second condition is violated, it is distorted.
9/5/21
SO - Member Nations Nebel T
Tournament: x | Round: Finals | Opponent: xX | Judge: Nebel T Email Interp: on this topic the aff can’t specify a subset of member nations.
9/4/21
SO - T Define IP
Tournament: Loyola | Round: 1 | Opponent: Proof DR | Judge: Abhishek Rao Interp: The aff must provide a delineated definition of intellectual property in the AC doc.