Presentation Jain Neg
| Tournament | Round | Opponent | Judge | Cites | Round Report | Open Source | Edit/Delete |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Glenbrooks | 3 | Little Rock Central BF | Sahil Chiniwala |
|
|
| |
| Glenbrooks | 6 | Coppell SK | Lawrence Zhou |
|
|
| |
| Glenbrooks | 2 | Hawken KJ | Joseph Keiklak |
|
|
| |
| xx | 1 | xx | xx |
|
|
|
| Tournament | Round | Report |
|---|---|---|
| Glenbrooks | 3 | Opponent: Little Rock Central BF | Judge: Sahil Chiniwala 1AC |
| Glenbrooks | 6 | Opponent: Coppell SK | Judge: Lawrence Zhou 1AC |
| Glenbrooks | 2 | Opponent: Hawken KJ | Judge: Joseph Keiklak 1AC |
| xx | 1 | Opponent: xx | Judge: xx xx |
To modify or delete round reports, edit the associated round.
Cites
| Entry | Date |
|---|---|
ND - CP Public Sector WorkersTournament: Glenbrooks | Round: 2 | Opponent: Hawken KJ | Judge: Joseph Keiklak ====READ: Strikes have prevented medicines from entering Puerto Rico, proving that there are risks to citizens in countries when strikes are allowed by the transportation industry. ==== Read: Public transportation is critical for women, Black, low-income, and young commuters. It disproportionately harms older individuals and those with disabilities, and is critical to food and employment access. These strikes harm those most in need.Heaps et al., '21 ~Wendy Heaps is senior policy analyst in the Office of The Associate Director for Policy and Strategy, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Erin Abramsohn is senior policy advisor in the Office of The Associate Director for Policy and Strategy, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Elizabeth Skillen is senior policy advisor in the Office of The Associate Director for Policy and Strategy, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Published: 7/29/21, "Public Transportation In The US: A Driver Of Health And Equity " Health Affairs, https://www.healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/hpb20210630.810356/full/ ~ /Triumph Debate MAYBE: Teacher strikes reduce the wages for teachers and result in declining educational performance by students. This falls primarily on those in the most vulnerable households.Jaume and Willén, '19 ~David Jaume is a deputy manager at the Bank of Mexico, Alexander Willén is an associate professor of economics at the Norwegian School of Economics, Published: 7/18/19, "The Long-Run Effects of Teacher Strikes: Evidence from Argentina " Journal of Labor Economics, https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/pdf/10.1086/703134?casa_token=tzq43kOEpvIAAAAA:wDjZCDihN9pfAX45InqiqiLkHdzG67cHwGnmgBSu4DKRS0DEDXHuWTmUf_EWwRjrHunlvPwLSDo ~ /Triumph Debate CP: Public SectorCounterplan: A Just government ought to introduce an unconditional right to strike for all workers, except for those in the public sector. Public sector strikes prevent governments from fulfilling their responsibilities to the people, which are essential to just government.Crepeau, Adam. "Allowing Public Employees To Strike Would Disrupt Our Schools And Communities." Maine Wire. August 08, 2019. Web. October 13, 2021. . Banning public transit strikes won't weaken unions—-transit workers have other effective methods for dispute resolution besides strikes.Biber, Eric. "Are Transit Strikes Bad For The Environment?" Legal Planet. January 03, 2014. Web. October 13, 2021. . Read: The right to strike should be constrained for public and essential services, instead, a variety of compensatory guarantees should be offered to both protect the public and the workers.Swepston, '98 ~Lee Swepston is a former ILO's Senior Adviser on Human rights as well as the chief of the ILO's Equality Branch and Human Rights Coordinator, Published: 1998, "Human rights law and freedom of association : development through ILO supervision" International Labour Review, https://labordoc.ilo.org/permalink/41ILO_INST/j3q9on/alma993308183402676 ~ /Triumph Debate | 11/22/21 |
ND - CP Public Sector Workers v2Tournament: Glenbrooks | Round: 6 | Opponent: Coppell SK | Judge: Lawrence Zhou Contention 1 – Public Sector Strikes are problematic - the Aff exacerbates this by making this unconditional====READ: Strikes have prevented medicines from entering Puerto Rico, proving that there are risks to citizens in countries when strikes are allowed by the transportation industry. ==== Read: Public transportation is critical for women, Black, low-income, and young commuters. It disproportionately harms older individuals and those with disabilities, and is critical to food and employment access. These strikes harm those most in need.Heaps et al., '21 ~Wendy Heaps is senior policy analyst in the Office of The Associate Director for Policy and Strategy, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Erin Abramsohn is senior policy advisor in the Office of The Associate Director for Policy and Strategy, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Elizabeth Skillen is senior policy advisor in the Office of The Associate Director for Policy and Strategy, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Published: 7/29/21, "Public Transportation In The US: A Driver Of Health And Equity " Health Affairs, https://www.healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/hpb20210630.810356/full/ ~ /Triumph Debate MAYBE: Teacher strikes reduce the wages for teachers and result in declining educational performance by students. This falls primarily on those in the most vulnerable households.Jaume and Willén, '19 ~David Jaume is a deputy manager at the Bank of Mexico, Alexander Willén is an associate professor of economics at the Norwegian School of Economics, Published: 7/18/19, "The Long-Run Effects of Teacher Strikes: Evidence from Argentina " Journal of Labor Economics, https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/pdf/10.1086/703134?casa_token=tzq43kOEpvIAAAAA:wDjZCDihN9pfAX45InqiqiLkHdzG67cHwGnmgBSu4DKRS0DEDXHuWTmUf_EWwRjrHunlvPwLSDo ~ /Triumph Debate CP: Public SectorCounterplan: A Just government ought to introduce an unconditional right to strike for all workers, except for those in the public sector. Public sector strikes prevent governments from fulfilling their responsibilities to the people, which are essential to just government.Crepeau, Adam. "Allowing Public Employees To Strike Would Disrupt Our Schools And Communities." Maine Wire. August 08, 2019. Web. October 13, 2021. . Banning public transit strikes won't weaken unions—-transit workers have other effective methods for dispute resolution besides strikes.Biber, Eric. "Are Transit Strikes Bad For The Environment?" Legal Planet. January 03, 2014. Web. October 13, 2021. . Read: The right to strike should be constrained for public and essential services, instead, a variety of compensatory guarantees should be offered to both protect the public and the workers.Swepston, '98 ~Lee Swepston is a former ILO's Senior Adviser on Human rights as well as the chief of the ILO's Equality Branch and Human Rights Coordinator, Published: 1998, "Human rights law and freedom of association : development through ILO supervision" International Labour Review, https://labordoc.ilo.org/permalink/41ILO_INST/j3q9on/alma993308183402676 ~ /Triumph Debate | 11/22/21 |
ND - PresumptionTournament: Glenbrooks | Round: 3 | Opponent: Little Rock Central BF | Judge: Sahil Chiniwala 1NC — CaseRead: 1NC — PresumptionVote negative on presumption – this aff solves nothing:
1~ Systems – all of their inherency is about external institutions and material conditions outside of debate. Their advocacy does not alter any of thoseor result in a breakdown of patriarchy writ large. They need to explain IN DETAIL what the aff's solvency mechanism is and how it changes the world.
2~ There's no ballot key warrant. At best, their solvency says introducing this refusal is effective to generate solidarity but NOWHERE does it say tying it to the ballot is good or necessary which means the aff has no inherency because they already introduced and read the 1AC.
We'll impact turn their attempt to attach the ballot to refusal and a liberation strategy:A~ It's a double turn with the aff's entire K of liberalism and humanism. It attaches their faux subversive method to the traditional liberal notions of communication and agonistic dialogue that they say exclude women.B~ Attaching liberation to the ballot in a competition is a violent model of debate. It puts the judge in an inappropriate position because it requires the judge decide we should be in solidarity with women and forces debaters to negate personal survival strategies. Debate's just a game and tasking the judge with determining whether someone's identity or personal resistance should be accepted is incredibly violentC~ It's a palliative —- giving —- a W does nothing to make debate better, and viewing ballots as currency for social movements is terminally unsustainable because losses are inevitable and can signal failure to advocates of their method.1NC — InfoshopThe 1ac is just an infoshop—an organization where radicals meet to discuss ideals in the abstract—this disconnection from society precludes any possibility or revolutionary change. True politics must occur at a level of class consciousness and organizing, they just recreate new elitism and maintain the status quo.Olson 2013 (Joel, associate professor at Northern Arizona University, "The problem with infoshops and insurrection US anarchism, movement building, and the racial order", 'Contemporary Anarchist Studies', published in 2013) Read: 1NC — Horizontalism BadTheir understanding of debate as spilling in demonstrates their fidelity to the present day carving out of spaces for freedom by radicals — this produces horizontalist modes of knowledge that lack a platform of organizingMarcus 12. associate book editor at Dissent Magazine (Fall, David, "The Horizontalists", http://www.dissentmagazine.org/article/the-horizontalists) 1NC — Identity Politics BadReform through the lens of identity politics tokenizes and commodifies minorities' suffering and kowtows to those who benefit from their oppression – idpol serves to maintain and reify the state and capitalism.Anonymous, 2012, "Identity, politics, and anti-politics: a critical perspective" 2012. http://libcom.org/library/identity-politics-anti-politics-critical-perspective Read: 1NC — Ballot badResistance via the ballot can only instill an adaptive politics of being and effaces the institutional constraints that reproduce the violent underside of liberalismBrown 95—prof at UC Berkeley (Wendy, States of Injury, 21-3) 1NC — Personal PTX BadStarting politics from a position of personal survival is a politics of resentment—it can only position itself reactively against the universal, inevitably re-instantiating the terms of oppression*We do not condone any of our authors' uses of gendered, ableist, or otherwise offensive language. We apologize in place of our authors* | 11/22/21 |
ND - T FrameworkTournament: Glenbrooks | Round: 3 | Opponent: Little Rock Central BF | Judge: Sahil Chiniwala 1NC — T — FWThe text of the resolution calls for debate on hypothetical government actionEricson 3 (Jon M., Dean Emeritus of the College of Liberal Arts – California Polytechnic U., et al., The Debater's Guide, Third Edition, p. 4) Vote Neg —Procedural Fairness — post facto topic change alters balance of prep, which structurally favors the aff because they speak last and get perms. Debate is a competition that necessitates boundaries and limits that ensure one side doesn't win by default. All of our specific strategies, link to disads, and specific actor and mechanisms are moot – This isn't conductive to a fair, educational debate.all 2AC defense to this claim will rely on concessionary ground which isn't a stable basis for a year of debate while all the aff has to do is find evidence supporting an ideological orientation towards the world.Clash —any alternative to our model of the topic as a baseline discussion wrecks the point of having a predictable stasis point which is the resolution. Their model of debate turns into a monologue that means their args are presumptively false because they haven't been tested by a well-researched opponent and encourages overly broad and not specific research to create policies that counter oppression which also reinforces dogmatism and precludes the refining of those strategies.Intellectual humility- Putting our positions up for debate and studying their flaws best breaks down our neural bias towards intellectual arrogance, and fosters a culture of better scholarship—-our brains are terrible at knowing when we're wrong and updating our beliefs. The impact is intellectual humility—-rewards bluster instead of thoroughness that trends us and society towards extreme, unvetted positions where we criticize without accepting criticism (Having a neg to argue against is essential to foster well thought out ideas and policies)SSD solves all of their offense – there is no independent reason as to why they can't read their nontopical advocacy as a K on the neg. Their model of debate produces insular debates that destroy education, ethics and reproduces violence– turns caseEvans 12 ~Rashad, JD., Black debate extraordinare and JD, "The 1NC," Nov 20, http://www.rwesq.com/the-1nc/~~ Anatomizing Power—-the aff's attempt to shift the focus away from the core imperial power of the USFG which reflects a privileged position that obscures national liberation movements and hinders them by removing pressure from the USFG.Maupin, 21 ~Caleb Maupin is a widely acclaimed speaker, writer, journalist, and political analyst. He has traveled extensively in the Middle East and in Latin America. He was involved with the Occupy Wall Street movement from its early planning stages, and has been involved many struggles for social justice. He is an outspoken advocate of international friendship and cooperation, as well as 21st Century Socialism. "Chapter Two: Redefining Capitalism and Socialism," 7/1/21, Midwestern Marx~Townes Tactics—-the aff conflates the most radical position with the most revolutionary - success isn't based on how you think but what you achieve which means that understanding the political state intimately is key to mobilizing effective tactics.Sims and Lynch, 21 ~Joe Sims is co-chair of the Communist Party USA (2019-). He is also a senior editor of People's World and loves biking.Maicol David Lynch is a member of the National Committee of the Communist Party USA and an activist and organizer in Working America and Indivisible. He writes from New York City and is most passionate about the struggles against imperialism in Latin America and the fight against xenophobia in immigrant communities in the USA. "The Socialist Moment and Mass Radicalization." 6/29/2021, Midwestern Marx~Townes Instead, the aff could talk about racialized capitalism while still staying in the bounds of Lincoln Douglas Debate: TVA — affirm the resolution with advantage areas about black workers and their exclusion from current labor movements | 11/22/21 |
ND - Unconditional RTS permits ViolenceTournament: Glenbrooks | Round: 2 | Opponent: Hawken KJ | Judge: Joseph Keiklak The first is unconditional: Unconditional strikes are problematic for several reasonsA~ Recognizing an unconditional right to strike permits violence. , I B~ Unconditional means emergencies too such as pandemics or wars, with no limits on what strikers do2. A just government: Before arguing about the actions of this just government I want to first define what it means to be a just government1 it protects the wellbeing, safety, and health of the people3~ and wont cause unnecessary harm to its neighboring nations | 11/22/21 |
ND - Uncondtional RTS permits Violence v2Tournament: Glenbrooks | Round: 6 | Opponent: Coppell SK | Judge: Lawrence Zhou The first is unconditional: Unconditional strikes are problematic for several reasonsA~ Recognizing an unconditional right to strike permits violence. , I B~ Unconditional means emergencies too such as pandemics or wars, with no limits on what strikers do2. A just government: Before arguing about the actions of this just government I want to first define what it means to be a just government1 it protects the wellbeing, safety, and health of the people3~ and wont cause unnecessary harm to its neighboring nations | 11/22/21 |
Open Source
| Filename | Date | Uploaded By | Delete |
|---|---|---|---|
11/22/21 | ajain24@presentationhsorg |
| |
11/22/21 | ajain24@presentationhsorg |
| |
11/22/21 | ajain24@presentationhsorg |
|