Marlborough Hannon Aff
| Tournament | Round | Opponent | Judge | Cites | Round Report | Open Source | Edit/Delete |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 - contact | 1 | x | x |
|
| ||
| Damus | 2 | Immaculate Heart SP | David Kilpatrick |
|
|
| |
| Loyola | 1 | Immac SS | Asher Towner |
|
|
| |
| Loyola | 3 | ModernBrain AK | Derek Hilligoss |
|
|
| |
| Presentation | 1 | Harker RM | Gordon Krauss |
|
|
| |
| Presentation | 4 | Harker AAn | Samantha McLoughlin |
|
|
| |
| Presentation | 6 | Harker AAn | Harker NA |
|
|
| |
| St Marks | 1 | Vestavia GJ | Leah Clark-Villanueva |
|
|
| |
| St Marks | 3 | Greenhill NT | Ari Davidson |
|
|
|
| Tournament | Round | Report |
|---|---|---|
| Damus | 2 | Opponent: Immaculate Heart SP | Judge: David Kilpatrick AC - incarcerated workers |
| Loyola | 1 | Opponent: Immac SS | Judge: Asher Towner AC - covid |
| Loyola | 3 | Opponent: ModernBrain AK | Judge: Derek Hilligoss AC - covid |
| Presentation | 1 | Opponent: Harker RM | Judge: Gordon Krauss AC - covid v3 |
| Presentation | 4 | Opponent: Harker AAn | Judge: Samantha McLoughlin AC - MSF |
| Presentation | 6 | Opponent: Harker AAn | Judge: Harker NA AC - covid v3 |
| St Marks | 1 | Opponent: Vestavia GJ | Judge: Leah Clark-Villanueva AC - covid |
| St Marks | 3 | Opponent: Greenhill NT | Judge: Ari Davidson AC - covid v4 |
To modify or delete round reports, edit the associated round.
Cites
| Entry | Date |
|---|---|
0 - contactTournament: 0 - contact | Round: 1 | Opponent: x | Judge: x | 9/4/21 |
SeptOct - Covid v2Tournament: Loyola | Round: 3 | Opponent: ModernBrain AK | Judge: Derek Hilligoss The only way to solve the pandemic is global vaccination, but current production is woefully short. Changing IP laws is key to combatting structural violence and vaccine apartheid. Rich countries hoard vaccine supply, which means donor models never solve and reinforce colonialism. Harman et al 6/21 Compulsory licensing is not sufficient – drug company resistance, IP thickets, and devolved decision-making. Vaccine shortfall causes widespread death and poverty. Poverty and disease are mutually reinforcing, causing staggering suffering and injustice. II. Solvency Legal certainty unlocks global production. Manufacturing capacity is widespread around the world. III. Capitalism The aff is uniquely anticapitalistic by taking away monopolies from vaccine producers. The aff’s focus on material conditions is key to generate practical and ideological resistance to capitalism. Purdy 20 Capitalism’s drive to accumulate compels environmental catastrophe and nuclear warfare --- we should mobilize accordingly IV. Framing | 9/4/21 |
SeptOct - Covid v3Tournament: Presentation | Round: 6 | Opponent: Harker AAn | Judge: Harker NA The only way to solve the pandemic is global vaccination, but current production is woefully short. Changing IP laws is key to combatting global health inequality and vaccine apartheid. Rich countries hoard vaccine supply, which means donor models never solve and reinforce colonialism. Harman et al 6/21 Compulsory licensing is not sufficient – drug company resistance, IP thickets, and devolved decision-making. Vaccine shortfall causes widespread death and poverty. Poverty and disease are mutually reinforcing, causing staggering suffering and injustice. II. Solvency A waiver would increase leverage over pharma and provide legal certainty needed to spur critical production. Legal certainty unlocks global production. Manufacturing capacity is widespread around the world. Underview (B) Compound Probability - Multiplied probabilities of long link chains have negligible net probabilities. This is the slippery slope fallacy. (C) Causal Direction - They will say the fractional probability of a huge impact still has a large expected value, but it’s impossible to determine the direction of low-probability links. Does the butterfly flapping its wings cause the hurricane or prevent it? Disregard tiny-probability links because they don’t guide decision-making. (D) Complexity – the DA presents a simplistic and deterministic narrative that fails to account for the myriad confounding factors that can disrupt or reverse the link chain of the DA. The most important of these is the probability that people will recognize the dangerous path they’re on and change course, e.g. leaders backing down during the Cuban Missile Crisis. (E) Decision Gridlock – Every course of action or inaction has a negligible possibility of causing extinction. This makes it impossible to prioritize averting existential risk over all else because such risk is unavoidable. We have no choice but to prioritize REALISTIC probabilities. (F) Apocalyptic rhetoric is an independent voter – justifies violence, trades off with addressing real risks, and causes nihilism. (G) Distrust low-probability predictions of catastrophe – subjectivity, cognitive bias, and history of failed predictions. | 10/11/21 |
SeptOct - Covid v4Tournament: St Marks | Round: 1 | Opponent: Vestavia GJ | Judge: Leah Clark-Villanueva The only way to solve the pandemic is global vaccination, but current production is woefully short. Changing IP laws is key to combatting global health inequality and vaccine apartheid. Rich countries hoard vaccine supply, which means donor models never solve and reinforce colonialism. Harman et al 6/21 Compulsory licensing is not sufficient – drug company resistance, IP thickets, and devolved decision-making. Vaccine shortfall causes widespread death and poverty. Poverty and disease are mutually reinforcing, causing staggering suffering and injustice. II. Solvency A waiver would increase leverage over pharma and provide legal certainty needed to spur critical production. Legal certainty unlocks global production. Manufacturing capacity is widespread around the world. III. Framing The Aff challenges the hegemonic ideology of the status quo by rejecting sacrificial rationalizations. That logic is the basis for colonialism, slavery, genocide, war, and global poverty. Reform makes revolution more likely. Rejecting it condescendingly asserts the possibility of radical change is better than the certainty of real improvement. | 10/16/21 |
SeptOct - MSF ACTournament: Presentation | Round: 4 | Opponent: Harker AAn | Judge: Samantha McLoughlin Millions die from pneumonia and HPV, but low-income countries and families can’t afford the vaccines to prevent them. Poverty and disease are mutually reinforcing, causing staggering suffering and injustice. Solvency Butler ’04 - Judith Butler Prof. of Rhetoric and Comparative Literature, University of California at Berkeley, Precarious Life: The Powers of Mourning and Violence. New York: Verso (2006; First Published 2004). pp. 30-35 AT Apocalyptic rhetoric is an independent voter – justifies violence, trades off with addressing real risks, and causes nihilism. | 10/9/21 |
SeptOct - covid v5Tournament: St Marks | Round: 3 | Opponent: Greenhill NT | Judge: Ari Davidson Manufacturing capacity is widespread around the world. III. Framing The Aff challenges the hegemonic ideology of the status quo by rejecting sacrificial rationalizations. That logic is the basis for colonialism, slavery, genocide, war, and global poverty. Adopt a hybridizing strategy - exploiting contradictions in hegemonic discourse maintains critical distance while effectively challenging the state. Kapoor ‘08 Reform makes revolution more likely. Rejecting it condescendingly asserts the possibility of radical change is better than the certainty of real improvement. | 10/16/21 |
Open Source
| Filename | Date | Uploaded By | Delete |
|---|---|---|---|
9/4/21 | juliannehannon22@marlboroughorg |
| |
9/4/21 | juliannehannon22@marlboroughorg |
| |
10/8/21 | juliannehannon22@marlboroughorg |
| |
10/9/21 | juliannehannon22@marlboroughorg |
| |
10/11/21 | juliannehannon22@marlboroughorg |
| |
10/16/21 | juliannehannon22@marlboroughorg |
| |
10/16/21 | juliannehannon22@marlboroughorg |
|