Lincoln Southeast Witte Aff
| Tournament | Round | Opponent | Judge | Cites | Round Report | Open Source | Edit/Delete |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Any | 1 | All | All |
|
|
| |
| Capital City Classic | 5 | Millard West MB | Michael Brooks |
|
|
| |
| NSDA Nebraska South District | 5 | Lincoln East EB | Dylan Sutton |
|
|
|
| Tournament | Round | Report |
|---|---|---|
| Any | 1 | Opponent: All | Judge: All *contact info |
| Capital City Classic | 5 | Opponent: Millard West MB | Judge: Michael Brooks NC bit into case hard 1AR strategy was to extend framing and case 2NR focused on blocking and extending blocks on my case 2AR solidified everything and won off framing |
| NSDA Nebraska South District | 5 | Opponent: Lincoln East EB | Judge: Dylan Sutton tried to close on defintion but couldn't quite |
To modify or delete round reports, edit the associated round.
Cites
| Entry | Date |
|---|---|
Col AFFTournament: Capital City Classic | Round: 5 | Opponent: Millard West MB | Judge: Michael Brooks I provide these definitions: Colonialism is a practice of domination The single standard is deconstructing colonialism The only way to establish a just, peaceful society is to deconstruct colonialism Bryne et al 18 1 Colonial societies are built on exclusion, and do not take many people into account. Deconstructing colonialism is the only way to allow those harmed by colonizing violence back into any consequentialist calculus, meaning this framework is a prerequisite to all consequentialist frameworks. Butler 03 Traditional moral theories cannot accomplish what is necessary to deconstruct colonialism, meaning this framework is a prerequisite to other frameworks. Bryne et al 18 2 The debate cannot just exclude those harmed by colonial violence. Contention 1: Colonialism creates structural violence Something as seemingly benign as medicine upholds violence in a colonial or postcolonial society. Keller 11 Violence from the colonial reality persists in indigenous communities, and can be passed on between generation and generation. Bombay et al 09 Contention 2: Space travel is colonialism Historically, space travel has completely relied on colonialism and its violence. Even now, it still relies on continuing domination. Durrani 19 The modern billionaire space race repeats the same ideologies that led to colonialism in the first place. McCormick 21 | 2/1/22 |
Contact InfoTournament: Any | Round: 1 | Opponent: All | Judge: All | 3/11/22 |
Journalism AFFTournament: NSDA Nebraska South District | Round: 5 | Opponent: Lincoln East EB | Judge: Dylan Sutton Observation: The AFF’s burden is to prove that the objectivity model ought to be prioritized over the advocacy model for a free press in a democracy Objectivity in journalism refers to a methodology of reporting facts in a way that is precise, consistent, and transparent. American Press Institute 22 This definition should be favored for these reasons:
2. Ground: - Gives the AFF more equal ground because AFF doesn’t have to prove objectivity exists. If debate allowed to be about objectivity existing, NEG would immediately close on just going for objectivity doesn’t exist, presumption vote. That gives NEG inequitably more ground and space to operate. That brings us to advocacy Smith and Reader 11 This definition should be favored for these reasons: Overview - Above card closes on broad definition how it is generally employed, not hyper minute definition. Works in broad generalities like the resolution. The single standard is minimizing oppression. First, this framing is a prerequisite to all other framings, because it is the only way to take everyone into account. Butler 03 Second, the debate cannot just exclude those harmed by oppression. Alston and Timmons 14 Contention 1: Corporate Capture Without the objective method, the press will publish pieces only serving to enrich the government and corporate sponsors. Vanderwicken 95 The NEG world is one where the press becomes advocates for corporations, not marginalized groups. The comparative is the objective method vs. corporate capture. An example of this is the Iraq War. The press didn’t advocate for Iraqi citizens, they advocated for corporate interests. Ludes 08 If the objective method was employed, the press wouldn’t have spun the war positively. The invasion was based on a lie that could’ve easily been uncovered with the objective method. The toll of the war was not little either, not a small thing that can be forgiven. Reuters Staff 08 This doesn’t count US deaths or the economic toll of the war even. With advocacy the press will continue to push harmful narratives content with the consequence of the deaths of millions. They have tried to redeem Iraq, and spur on new interventions. Hammond et al. 19 Objective journalism is crucial for education as it allows one to get facts, and not just a journalist’s interpretation. Williams and Stroud 20 Education is crucial to minimizing oppression as it is a way to achieve liberation. Sanga 17 | 3/16/22 |
Open Source
| Filename | Date | Uploaded By | Delete |
|---|---|---|---|
2/1/22 | smackandcheese24@gmailcom |
|