Isidore Newman Elliott Aff
| Tournament | Round | Opponent | Judge | Cites | Round Report | Open Source | Edit/Delete |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 - Contact Info | 1 | Contact Info | Contact Info |
|
|
| |
| 1 - Grapevine | 1 | Lexington AR | Chansey Agler |
|
|
| |
| 1 - Grapevine | 3 | Harrison JC | Claudia Ribera |
|
|
| |
| 10 - Emory | 4 | Marlbo VA | Alex Berry |
|
|
| |
| 12 - Cal rr | 3 | Marlbo WR | Panel |
|
|
| |
| 14 - TOC | 3 | Mission San Jose SR | Rose Larson |
|
|
| |
| 14 - TOC | Triples | Lake Highland Prep AB | Panel |
|
|
| |
| 2 - DTA | 2 | Stockdale RP | John Fruge |
|
|
| |
| 2 - DTA | 3 | Roeper RL | May Duong |
|
|
| |
| 2 - DTA | 5 | Christopher Columbus AM | Megan Broussard |
|
|
| |
| 2 - DTA | Octas | Hamilton Independent GB | Panel |
|
|
| |
| 2 - DTA | Quarters | West Des Moines Valley AM | Panel |
|
|
| |
| 3 - JWP | 2 | Harvard Westlake AT | Tajaih Robinson |
|
|
| |
| 3 - JWP | 3 | Little Rock Central XJ | Kelley Kirkpatrick |
|
|
| |
| 3 - JWP | Semis | Memorial SC | Panel |
|
|
| |
| 3 - JWP | Finals | Harvard-Westlake IC | Panel |
|
|
| |
| 3 - JWP | 6 | Brophy SA | Amanda Nobra |
|
|
| |
| 4 - Applevalley | 1 | Troy Independent AP | Brixz Gonzaba |
|
|
| |
| 5 - Glenbrooks | 5 | Harker RM | Andrew Wixson |
|
|
| |
| 6 - Blake | 1 | Lexington AG | Kaya Czyz |
|
|
| |
| 6 - Blake | 4 | Scarsdale DH | Devin Hernandez |
|
|
| |
| 7 - Sunvite | 2 | Durham JH | Alex Rivera |
|
|
| |
| 8 - HW Challenge | 1 | Harker AR | Panel |
|
|
| |
| 8 - HW Challenge | 4 | Marlbo WR | Panel |
|
|
| |
| 9 - Harvard Westlake | 2 | Harker SS | Ari Davidson |
|
|
|
| Tournament | Round | Report |
|---|---|---|
| 0 - Contact Info | 1 | Opponent: Contact Info | Judge: Contact Info Contact Info |
| 1 - Grapevine | 1 | Opponent: Lexington AR | Judge: Chansey Agler 1AC - Hauntology V 1 |
| 1 - Grapevine | 3 | Opponent: Harrison JC | Judge: Claudia Ribera 1AC - Hauntology v 2 |
| 10 - Emory | 4 | Opponent: Marlbo VA | Judge: Alex Berry 1AC - PTD |
| 12 - Cal rr | 3 | Opponent: Marlbo WR | Judge: Panel 1AC - PTD v6 |
| 14 - TOC | 3 | Opponent: Mission San Jose SR | Judge: Rose Larson 1AC |
| 14 - TOC | Triples | Opponent: Lake Highland Prep AB | Judge: Panel 1AC |
| 2 - DTA | 2 | Opponent: Stockdale RP | Judge: John Fruge 1AC - Stock Aff |
| 2 - DTA | 3 | Opponent: Roeper RL | Judge: May Duong 1AC - Stock Aff v1 |
| 2 - DTA | 5 | Opponent: Christopher Columbus AM | Judge: Megan Broussard 1AC - Stock Aff v1 |
| 2 - DTA | Octas | Opponent: Hamilton Independent GB | Judge: Panel 1AC - Hauntology v2 |
| 2 - DTA | Quarters | Opponent: West Des Moines Valley AM | Judge: Panel 1AC - Stock Aff v1 |
| 3 - JWP | 2 | Opponent: Harvard Westlake AT | Judge: Tajaih Robinson 1AC - Hauntology v 3 |
| 3 - JWP | 3 | Opponent: Little Rock Central XJ | Judge: Kelley Kirkpatrick 1AC - Huantology v4 |
| 3 - JWP | Semis | Opponent: Memorial SC | Judge: Panel 1AC - Hauntology v3 |
| 3 - JWP | Finals | Opponent: Harvard-Westlake IC | Judge: Panel 1AC - Hauntology v3 |
| 3 - JWP | 6 | Opponent: Brophy SA | Judge: Amanda Nobra 1AC - Stock v2 (check os cites refuse to work for this round) |
| 4 - Applevalley | 1 | Opponent: Troy Independent AP | Judge: Brixz Gonzaba 1AC - Hauntology v1 (novdec) |
| 5 - Glenbrooks | 5 | Opponent: Harker RM | Judge: Andrew Wixson 1AC - Hauntology V2 |
| 6 - Blake | 1 | Opponent: Lexington AG | Judge: Kaya Czyz 1AC Ptd v 1 |
| 6 - Blake | 4 | Opponent: Scarsdale DH | Judge: Devin Hernandez 1AC - PTD V2 |
| 7 - Sunvite | 2 | Opponent: Durham JH | Judge: Alex Rivera 1AC - PTD v3 |
| 8 - HW Challenge | 1 | Opponent: Harker AR | Judge: Panel 1AC - Hauntolgoy v1 |
| 8 - HW Challenge | 4 | Opponent: Marlbo WR | Judge: Panel 1AC - Hauntolgoy v2 |
| 9 - Harvard Westlake | 2 | Opponent: Harker SS | Judge: Ari Davidson 1AC - PTD V4 |
To modify or delete round reports, edit the associated round.
Cites
| Entry | Date |
|---|---|
0 - Contact InfoTournament: 0 - Contact Info | Round: 1 | Opponent: Contact Info | Judge: Contact Info Cites for Stock v2 (JWP RD 6 are broken) | 10/10/21 |
JanFeb - Hauntology v1Tournament: 8 - HW Challenge | Round: 1 | Opponent: Harker AR | Judge: Panel Space and technology are uniquely locked in a cycle of hauntological repetition—The Mayflower becomes the spaceship.Catherine Emma Green 17, 4-2017, "Spectral Afterlife: Hauntology, Historical Memory, and Inheritance in Postmodernist Fiction," https://digitalcollections.wesleyan.edu/islandora/object/ir:723/datastream/PDF/view. ingp ====We control the root cause – all negative privatization good offense is haunted by manufactured risks ==== The aff is spectrality – only a critical interrogation of the present and the past as singular, totalizing, and complete can prevent the obstruction of possibility.Zembylas 13 – Associate Professor of Educational Theory and Curriculum Studies at the Open University of Cyprus (Michalinos, "Pedagogies of Hauntology In History Education: Learning to Live with the Ghosts of Disappeared Victims of War and Dictatorship," DOI: 10.1111/edth.12010, February 2013)DD ====Thus I affirm the Resolved: The appropriation of outer space by private entities is unjust. ==== ====The role of the ballot is to frontline reconciling with the past and the present ==== Epistemology comes first—-their model of debate risks extinction and turns their framing arguments.Heron 8. Taitu Heron, The Planning Institute of Jamaica. "Globalization, neoliberalism and the exercise of human agency." International Journal of Politics, Culture, and Society 20.1-4 (2008): 85-101.
Our offense turns policy making —- Our ontology is key to policymaking because it's the baseline to the process —- they effect one anotherSin 14 —- post-doctoral researcher, Centre for Research in Higher Education Policies (Cristina Sin, "The policy object: a different perspective on policy enactment in higher education," Proquest, 2/8/14, https://link-springer-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/content/pdf/10.10072Fs10734-014-9721-5.pdf)//lyss Notion of ethics is based on linguistically structured truth claims that reifies hegemonic violence.Forte 7 – Ph.D. in Japanese Buddhism, ethics, and continental philosophy from Temple University, Philadelphia (Victor, "The Ethics of Attainment The meaning of the ethical in Dogen and Derrida," From: Deconstruction and the Ethical in Asian Thought, Edited by Youru Wang, Routledge, 2007)DD Utilitarianism causes genocide.Santos 3 2003, Boaventura de Souza Santos is a Professor of Sociology at the University of Coimbra, "Collective Suicide?", Bad Subjects, Issue ~# 63 , http://www.ces.fe.uc.pt/opiniao/bss/072en.php | 1/13/22 |
JanFeb - Hauntology v2Tournament: 8 - HW Challenge | Round: 4 | Opponent: Marlbo WR | Judge: Panel Space and technology are uniquely locked in a cycle of hauntological repetition—the Mayflower becomes the spaceship.Catherine Emma Green 17, 4-2017, "Spectral Afterlife: Hauntology, Historical Memory, and Inheritance in Postmodernist Fiction," https://digitalcollections.wesleyan.edu/islandora/object/ir:723/datastream/PDF/view. ingp The aff is spectrality – only a critical interrogation of the present and the past as singular, totalizing, and complete can prevent the obstruction of possibility.Zembylas 13 – Associate Professor of Educational Theory and Curriculum Studies at the Open University of Cyprus (Michalinos, "Pedagogies of Hauntology In History Education: Learning to Live with the Ghosts of Disappeared Victims of War and Dictatorship," DOI: 10.1111/edth.12010, February 2013)DD Embracing these specters is key to solve for violence – anything other method justifies erasing all traces that disturb the self-enclosure of the present and turns all impacts.Papastephanou 11 – Associate Professor in the Department of Education at the University of Cyprus (Marianna, "Material Specters: International Conflicts, Disaster Management, and Educational Projects," Educational Theory, Volume 61, Number 1, 2011, pgs. 113-114)DD ====Thus I affirm the Resolved: The appropriation of outer space by private entities is unjust. ==== ====The role of the ballot is to frontline reconciling with the past and the present ==== Epistemology comes first—-their model of debate risks extinction and turns their framing arguments.Heron 8. Taitu Heron, The Planning Institute of Jamaica. "Globalization, neoliberalism and the exercise of human agency." International Journal of Politics, Culture, and Society 20.1-4 (2008): 85-101.
Our offense turns policy making —- Our ontology is key to policymaking because it's the baseline to the process —- they effect one anotherSin 14 —- post-doctoral researcher, Centre for Research in Higher Education Policies (Cristina Sin, "The policy object: a different perspective on policy enactment in higher education," Proquest, 2/8/14, https://link-springer-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/content/pdf/10.10072Fs10734-014-9721-5.pdf)//lyss Notion of ethics is based on linguistically structured truth claims that reifies hegemonic violence.Forte 7 – Ph.D. in Japanese Buddhism, ethics, and continental philosophy from Temple University, Philadelphia (Victor, "The Ethics of Attainment The meaning of the ethical in Dogen and Derrida," From: Deconstruction and the Ethical in Asian Thought, Edited by Youru Wang, Routledge, 2007)DD Utilitarianism without hauntology causes genocide.Santos 3 2003, Boaventura de Souza Santos is a Professor of Sociology at the University of Coimbra, "Collective Suicide?", Bad Subjects, Issue ~# 63 , http://www.ces.fe.uc.pt/opiniao/bss/072en.php | 1/14/22 |
JanFeb - PTD v1Tournament: 6 - Blake | Round: 1 | Opponent: Lexington AG | Judge: Kaya Czyz Advantage 1: Space ColExpansion of PTD key to global space sustainabilityBabcock '19 — Hope M. Babcock, Professor of Law, Georgetown University Law Center, B.A., Smith College, L.L.B., Yale University; (2019; "ARTICLE: THE PUBLIC TRUST DOCTRINE, OUTER SPACE, AND THE GLOBAL COMMONS: TIME TO CALL HOME ET"; University of Michigan Libraries, Nexis Uni; Syracuse University Law Review, Vol. 69; LFS—JCM) Colonization solves inevitable extinction.Kovic '19 ~~~Marko; March 2019; co-founder president of the Zurich Institute of Public Affairs Research; "The future of energy," https://osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/aswz9/download~~~~~~ Judicial remedies are key – experience and capacity means they can resolve publicPlanThe appropriation of outer space by private entities is unjust without the expansion or creation of the public trust doctrine over outer space.Rauenzahn et al., 20 (Brianna Rauenzahn is a JD candidate at Penn and writer for the regulatory review, Jasmine Wang is a writer for the regulatory review, Jamison Chung, Peter Jacobs, Aaron Kaufman, and Hannah Pugh, 6-6-2020, accessed on 9-12-2021, The Regulatory Review, "Regulating Commercial Space Activity", https://www.theregreview.org/2020/06/06/saturday-seminar-regulating-commercial-space-activity/, HBisevac) Advantage 2: DebrisCurrent international guidelines can't sufficiently mitigate debris – past studies fail to assume the exponential rise in launches which makes more remediation necessaryBrian G. Chow 18, an independent policy analyst with over 25 years as a senior physical scientist specializing in space and national security. He holds a PhD in physics from Case Western Reserve University and an MBA with distinction and PhD in finance from the University of Michigan, "Space Arms Control: A Hybrid Approach," https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/26430818.pdf?refreqid=excelsior3A5c3c9eb9129d569ffff0fca50581bec9 Global mitigation and remediation in conjunction are necessary to solve the Kessler effect.Rada Popova 18, European Space Agency Co-Manager, PhD, Faculty of Law @ Universitat zu Koln, postgraduate degree from the Hague Academy for International Law, "The Legal Framework for Space Debris Remediation as a Tool for Sustainability in Outer Space," Aerospace, MDPI, doi:10.3390/aerospace5020055 *adr = active debris removal, sdr = space debris remediation, OOS = on orbit servicing Scenario 1: RadiationCollisions with nuclear spacecraft radiate the globe.Yuri Zaitsev 9, academic adviser with the Russian Academy of Engineering Sciences, '9, "Russia to develop nuclear-powered spacecraft for Mars mission" http://en.rian.ru/analysis/20091111/156797969.html That kills five billion people.Karl Grossman 96, professor of journalism at the State University of New York/College of New York, '96, "Risking the World: Nuclear Proliferation in Space," Covert Action Quarterly, Summer 1996 Scenario 2: MiscalcDebris triggers miscalculated war.Peter Dockrill 16. Award-winning science and technology journalist. "Space Junk Accidents Could Trigger Armed Conflict, Study Finds." https://www.sciencealert.com/space-junk-accidents-could-trigger-armed-conflict-expert-warns. Scenario 3: WarmingSpace Debris trades off with effective warming mitigationManner 21 ~~~Jennifer Manneris senior vice president of regulatory affairs at Hughes Network Systems. 7-27-2021, "Utilizing space to fight climate change on Earth," TheHill, https://thehill.com/opinion/energy-environment/565054-utilizing-space-to-fight-climate-change-on-earth~~~~~~/ISEE Climate Change is existentialNg '19 ~~~Yew-Kwang; May 2019; Professor of Economics at Nanyang Technology University, Fellow of the Academy of Social Sciences in Australia and Member of the Advisory Board at the Global Priorities Institute at Oxford University, Ph.D. in Economics from Sydney University; Global Policy, "Keynote: Global Extinction and Animal Welfare: Two Priorities for Effective Altruism," vol. 10, no. 2, p. 258-266; RP~~~ AND autonomous outsourcing—-extinctionKlare and Perry '21 — Michael Klare, Five College, professor emeritus of peace and world security studies, and director of the Five College Program in Peace and World Security Studies, B.A. and M.A. from Columbia University and a Ph.D. from the Graduate School of the Union Institute, serves on the board of the Arms Control Association and advises other organizations; Lucas Perry, interviewer; (July 30th 2021; "Michael Klare on the Pentagon's view of Climate Change and the Risks of State Collapse"; Future of Life Institute; https://futureoflife.org/2021/07/30/michael-klare-on-the-pentagons-view-of-climate-change-and-the-risks-of-state-collapse/?cn-reloaded=1; LFS—JCM) FramingUtil Its good —-Death is the worst thing under any ethical theory since it forecloses the possibility of any future value.Paterson 03, Craig ~~~Department of Philosophy, Providence College, Rhode Island~~~ 2003, "A Life Not Worth Living?", Studies in Christian Ethics Space scenario planning – independent of fiat – is valuable.Albright, 12—M.A. candidate in China-U.S. Relations, University of Hawai'i (Scott, "Demilitarizing Space: How Media and Non-State Powers Can Restrain U.S. and PRC Military Activities in Outer Space," Spring 2012, ProQuest, dml) | 12/18/21 |
JanFeb - PTD v2Tournament: 6 - Blake | Round: 4 | Opponent: Scarsdale DH | Judge: Devin Hernandez Advantage 1: Space ColExpansion of PTD key to global space sustainabilityBabcock '19 — Hope M. Babcock, Professor of Law, Georgetown University Law Center, B.A., Smith College, L.L.B., Yale University; (2019; "ARTICLE: THE PUBLIC TRUST DOCTRINE, OUTER SPACE, AND THE GLOBAL COMMONS: TIME TO CALL HOME ET"; University of Michigan Libraries, Nexis Uni; Syracuse University Law Review, Vol. 69; LFS—JCM) Colonization solves inevitable extinction.Kovic '19 ~Marko; March 2019; co-founder president of the Zurich Institute of Public Affairs Research; "The future of energy," https://osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/aswz9/download~~ PlanStates ought to establish an international public trust obligation towards protection of outer space as a refusal of the appropriation of outer space by private entities.Rauenzahn et al., 20 (Brianna Rauenzahn is a JD candidate at Penn and writer for the regulatory review, Jasmine Wang is a writer for the regulatory review, Jamison Chung, Peter Jacobs, Aaron Kaufman, and Hannah Pugh, 6-6-2020, accessed on 9-12-2021, The Regulatory Review, "Regulating Commercial Space Activity", https://www.theregreview.org/2020/06/06/saturday-seminar-regulating-commercial-space-activity/, HBisevac) Advantage 2: DebrisCurrent international guidelines can't sufficiently mitigate debris – past studies fail to assume the exponential rise in launches which makes more remediation necessaryBrian G. Chow 18, an independent policy analyst with over 25 years as a senior physical scientist specializing in space and national security. He holds a PhD in physics from Case Western Reserve University and an MBA with distinction and PhD in finance from the University of Michigan, "Space Arms Control: A Hybrid Approach," https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/26430818.pdf?refreqid=excelsior3A5c3c9eb9129d569ffff0fca50581bec9 ====Expanding the PTD over outerspace creates the regulatory framework necessary to regulate space debris==== Global mitigation and remediation in conjunction are necessary to solve the Kessler effect.Rada Popova 18, European Space Agency Co-Manager, PhD, Faculty of Law @ Universitat zu Koln, postgraduate degree from the Hague Academy for International Law, "The Legal Framework for Space Debris Remediation as a Tool for Sustainability in Outer Space," Aerospace, MDPI, doi:10.3390/aerospace5020055 *adr = active debris removal, sdr = space debris remediation, OOS = on orbit servicing Scenario 1: RadiationCollisions with nuclear spacecraft radiate the globe.Yuri Zaitsev 9, academic adviser with the Russian Academy of Engineering Sciences, '9, "Russia to develop nuclear-powered spacecraft for Mars mission" http://en.rian.ru/analysis/20091111/156797969.html That kills five billion people.Karl Grossman 96, professor of journalism at the State University of New York/College of New York, '96, "Risking the World: Nuclear Proliferation in Space," Covert Action Quarterly, Summer 1996 Scenario 2: MiscalcDebris triggers miscalculated war.Peter Dockrill 16. Award-winning science and technology journalist. "Space Junk Accidents Could Trigger Armed Conflict, Study Finds." https://www.sciencealert.com/space-junk-accidents-could-trigger-armed-conflict-expert-warns. ====It goes nuclear.==== Scenario 3: WarmingSpace Debris trades off with effective warming mitigationManner 21 ~Jennifer Manneris senior vice president of regulatory affairs at Hughes Network Systems. 7-27-2021, "Utilizing space to fight climate change on Earth," TheHill, https://thehill.com/opinion/energy-environment/565054-utilizing-space-to-fight-climate-change-on-earth~~/ISEE Climate Change is existentialNg '19 ~Yew-Kwang; May 2019; Professor of Economics at Nanyang Technology University, Fellow of the Academy of Social Sciences in Australia and Member of the Advisory Board at the Global Priorities Institute at Oxford University, Ph.D. in Economics from Sydney University; Global Policy, "Keynote: Global Extinction and Animal Welfare: Two Priorities for Effective Altruism," vol. 10, no. 2, p. 258-266; RP~ AND autonomous outsourcing—-extinctionKlare and Perry '21 — Michael Klare, Five College, professor emeritus of peace and world security studies, and director of the Five College Program in Peace and World Security Studies, B.A. and M.A. from Columbia University and a Ph.D. from the Graduate School of the Union Institute, serves on the board of the Arms Control Association and advises other organizations; Lucas Perry, interviewer; (July 30th 2021; "Michael Klare on the Pentagon's view of Climate Change and the Risks of State Collapse"; Future of Life Institute; https://futureoflife.org/2021/07/30/michael-klare-on-the-pentagons-view-of-climate-change-and-the-risks-of-state-collapse/?cn-reloaded=1; LFS—JCM) FramingUtil Its good —-Death is the worst thing under any ethical theory since it forecloses the possibility of any future value.Paterson 03, Craig ~Department of Philosophy, Providence College, Rhode Island~ 2003, "A Life Not Worth Living?", Studies in Christian Ethics Space scenario planning – independent of fiat – is valuable.Albright, 12—M.A. candidate in China-U.S. Relations, University of Hawai'i (Scott, "Demilitarizing Space: How Media and Non-State Powers Can Restrain U.S. and PRC Military Activities in Outer Space," Spring 2012, ProQuest, dml) | 12/19/21 |
JanFeb - PTD v3Tournament: 7 - Sunvite | Round: 2 | Opponent: Durham JH | Judge: Alex Rivera Advantage 1: Space ColExpansion of PTD key to global space sustainabilityBabcock '19 — Hope M. Babcock, Professor of Law, Georgetown University Law Center, B.A., Smith College, L.L.B., Yale University; (2019; "ARTICLE: THE PUBLIC TRUST DOCTRINE, OUTER SPACE, AND THE GLOBAL COMMONS: TIME TO CALL HOME ET"; University of Michigan Libraries, Nexis Uni; Syracuse University Law Review, Vol. 69; LFS—JCM) Colonization solves inevitable extinction.Kovic '19 ~Marko; March 2019; co-founder president of the Zurich Institute of Public Affairs Research; "The future of energy," https://osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/aswz9/download~~ PlanStates ought to establish an international public trust obligation towards protection of outer space as a refusal of the appropriation of outer space by private entities.Rauenzahn et al., 20 (Brianna Rauenzahn is a JD candidate at Penn and writer for the regulatory review, Jasmine Wang is a writer for the regulatory review, Jamison Chung, Peter Jacobs, Aaron Kaufman, and Hannah Pugh, 6-6-2020, accessed on 9-12-2021, The Regulatory Review, "Regulating Commercial Space Activity", https://www.theregreview.org/2020/06/06/saturday-seminar-regulating-commercial-space-activity/, HBisevac) Advantage 2: DebrisCurrent international guidelines can't sufficiently mitigate debris – past studies fail to assume the exponential rise in launches which makes more remediation necessaryBrian G. Chow 18, an independent policy analyst with over 25 years as a senior physical scientist specializing in space and national security. He holds a PhD in physics from Case Western Reserve University and an MBA with distinction and PhD in finance from the University of Michigan, "Space Arms Control: A Hybrid Approach," https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/26430818.pdf?refreqid=excelsior3A5c3c9eb9129d569ffff0fca50581bec9 ====Expanding the PTD over outerspace creates the regulatory framework necessary to regulate space debris==== Global mitigation and remediation in conjunction are necessary to solve the Kessler effect.Rada Popova 18, European Space Agency Co-Manager, PhD, Faculty of Law @ Universitat zu Koln, postgraduate degree from the Hague Academy for International Law, "The Legal Framework for Space Debris Remediation as a Tool for Sustainability in Outer Space," Aerospace, MDPI, doi:10.3390/aerospace5020055 *adr = active debris removal, sdr = space debris remediation, OOS = on orbit servicing Scenario 1: RadiationCollisions with nuclear spacecraft radiate the globe.Yuri Zaitsev 9, academic adviser with the Russian Academy of Engineering Sciences, '9, "Russia to develop nuclear-powered spacecraft for Mars mission" http://en.rian.ru/analysis/20091111/156797969.html That kills five billion people.Karl Grossman 96, professor of journalism at the State University of New York/College of New York, '96, "Risking the World: Nuclear Proliferation in Space," Covert Action Quarterly, Summer 1996 Scenario 2: MiscalcDebris triggers miscalculated war.Peter Dockrill 16. Award-winning science and technology journalist. "Space Junk Accidents Could Trigger Armed Conflict, Study Finds." https://www.sciencealert.com/space-junk-accidents-could-trigger-armed-conflict-expert-warns. ====It goes nuclear.==== FramingUtil Its good —-Its good —-1~ Effective debate necessitates primary focus on material violence— anything else ignores oppression.Dr. Tommy J. Curry 14, ~Dr. Curry is a Prof of Philosophy at Texas AandM University, Ray A. Rothrock Fellow 13'-16' and currently the USC Shoah Foundation 2016-17 A.I. and Manet Schepps Foundation Teaching Fellow, first Black JV National Debate champion (for UMKC) and half of the first all-Black CEDA team to win Pi Kappa Delta~ 2014, "The Cost of a Thing: A Kingian Reformulation of a Living Wage Argument in the 21st Century," http://www.academia.edu/9798210/The_Cost_of_a_Thing_A_Kingian_Reformulation_of_a_Living_Wage_Argument_in_the_21st_Century Brackets in original 2~ Actor spec—a. governments have to aggregate since all collective actions incur tradeoffs that help some and hurt other, means based side constraints freeze action.b. no act omission distinction for governments since policies create permissions and prohibitions so authorizing action cannot be an omission since the state assumes culpability in regulating the public domain, ie voting against something is still acting.c. no intent foresight distinction— governments can't have intent since they're made up of multiple actors with separate motivations, ie some congress people might vote for something to gain votes while other actually think the bill is good.Takes out and turns calc indicts, consequentialism might be hard but it's not impossible, and the alternative is no action which is worse; and actor spec outweighs since different actors have different ethical standings.3~ Substitutability— only consequentialism explains necessary enablers.Sinnott-Armstrong 92— Walter Sinnott-Armstrong, ~Professor of practical ethics~ 1992, "An Argument for Consequentialism" Dartmouth College Philosophical Perspectives 4~ Weighability— only consequentialism explains degrees of wrongness— you can only explain why breaking a promise to take a dying person to the hospital is worse than breaking a promise to meet for lunch by appealing to consequences.5~ Use epistemic modesty— that's the probability of the framework being true times the magnitude of an impact under it.a. substantively true: maximizes the probability of the most moral value; arguments against a framework mitigate offense under it but that mitigation is contingent, half the debate shouldn't be thrown out just since someone's 1 ahead on fwk.b. clash: discourages debaters from ignoring contention level debate which means we get education about phil and the topic— topical ed outweighs since we only have 2 months for each topic; this is drop the arg.Evaluate consequences – not doing so is morally bankruptDaase and Friesendorf 10 (Daase; Christopher Daase; professor at the Goethe University Frankfurt and head of the program area International Organizations and International Law at the Peace Research Institute Frankfurt; Friesendorf; Cornelius Friesendorf; lecturer at the Goethe University Frankfurt and research fellow at the Peace Research Institute Frankfurt; "Rethinking Security Governance: the problem of unintended consequences"; Routledge; 2010; pp 205-207; http://202.166.170.213:8080/xmlui/bitstream/handle/123456789/1343/Rethinking20Security20Governance20The20problem20of20unintended20consequences20by20Christopher20Daase.pdf?sequence=1andisAllowed=y~~#page=99) ~DTD~ | 1/8/22 |
JanFeb - PTD v4Tournament: 9 - Harvard Westlake | Round: 2 | Opponent: Harker SS | Judge: Ari Davidson Advantage 1: Space ColExpansion of PTD key to global space sustainabilityBabcock '19 — Hope M. Babcock, Professor of Law, Georgetown University Law Center, B.A., Smith College, L.L.B., Yale University; (2019; "ARTICLE: THE PUBLIC TRUST DOCTRINE, OUTER SPACE, AND THE GLOBAL COMMONS: TIME TO CALL HOME ET"; University of Michigan Libraries, Nexis Uni; Syracuse University Law Review, Vol. 69; LFS—JCM) Colonization solves inevitable extinction.Kovic '19 ~Marko; March 2019; co-founder president of the Zurich Institute of Public Affairs Research; "The future of energy," https://osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/aswz9/download~~ PlanStates ought to establish an international public trust obligation towards protection of outer space as a refusal of the appropriation of outer space by private entities.Rauenzahn et al., 20 (Brianna Rauenzahn is a JD candidate at Penn and writer for the regulatory review, Jasmine Wang is a writer for the regulatory review, Jamison Chung, Peter Jacobs, Aaron Kaufman, and Hannah Pugh, 6-6-2020, accessed on 9-12-2021, The Regulatory Review, "Regulating Commercial Space Activity", https://www.theregreview.org/2020/06/06/saturday-seminar-regulating-commercial-space-activity/, HBisevac) Advantage 2: DebrisCurrent international guidelines can't sufficiently mitigate debris – past studies fail to assume the exponential rise in launches which makes more remediation necessaryBrian G. Chow 18, an independent policy analyst with over 25 years as a senior physical scientist specializing in space and national security. He holds a PhD in physics from Case Western Reserve University and an MBA with distinction and PhD in finance from the University of Michigan, "Space Arms Control: A Hybrid Approach," https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/26430818.pdf?refreqid=excelsior3A5c3c9eb9129d569ffff0fca50581bec9 ====Expanding the PTD over outerspace creates the regulatory framework necessary to regulate space debris==== Global mitigation and remediation in conjunction are necessary to solve the Kessler effect.Rada Popova 18, European Space Agency Co-Manager, PhD, Faculty of Law @ Universitat zu Koln, postgraduate degree from the Hague Academy for International Law, "The Legal Framework for Space Debris Remediation as a Tool for Sustainability in Outer Space," Aerospace, MDPI, doi:10.3390/aerospace5020055 *adr = active debris removal, sdr = space debris remediation, OOS = on orbit servicing Scenario 1: Solar StormsStable satellites are key to solving grid collapse from solar stormsBoyle, 17 (Rebecca Boyle is an award-winning freelance journalist for The Atlantic and FiveThirtyEight and has twice been anthologized in the Best American Science and Nature Writing, 6-14-2017, accessed on 9-20-2021, NBC News, "How We'll Safeguard Earth From a Solar Storm Catastrophe", https://www.nbcnews.com/mach/space/how-we-ll-safeguard-earth-solar-storm-catastrophe-n760021, HBisevac) AND space weather catastrophes ensure extinctionRosen, 16 (Julia Rosen is a science reporter for the Los Angeles Times with a PhD in geology, accessed on 10-20-2021, Science.org, 7-14-2016, "Here's how the world could end—and what we can do about it", https://www.science.org/content/article/here-s-how-world-could-end-and-what-we-can-do-about-it-rev2, HBisevac) Scenario 2: MiscalcDebris triggers miscalculated war.Peter Dockrill 16. Award-winning science and technology journalist. "Space Junk Accidents Could Trigger Armed Conflict, Study Finds." https://www.sciencealert.com/space-junk-accidents-could-trigger-armed-conflict-expert-warns. ====It goes nuclear.==== FramingUtil Its good —-Its good —-1~ Effective debate necessitates primary focus on material violence— anything else ignores oppression.Dr. Tommy J. Curry 14, ~Dr. Curry is a Prof of Philosophy at Texas AandM University, Ray A. Rothrock Fellow 13'-16' and currently the USC Shoah Foundation 2016-17 A.I. and Manet Schepps Foundation Teaching Fellow, first Black JV National Debate champion (for UMKC) and half of the first all-Black CEDA team to win Pi Kappa Delta~ 2014, "The Cost of a Thing: A Kingian Reformulation of a Living Wage Argument in the 21st Century," http://www.academia.edu/9798210/The_Cost_of_a_Thing_A_Kingian_Reformulation_of_a_Living_Wage_Argument_in_the_21st_Century Brackets in original 2~ Actor spec—a. governments have to aggregate since all collective actions incur tradeoffs that help some and hurt other, means based side constraints freeze action.b. no act omission distinction for governments since policies create permissions and prohibitions so authorizing action cannot be an omission since the state assumes culpability in regulating the public domain, ie voting against something is still acting.c. no intent foresight distinction— governments can't have intent since they're made up of multiple actors with separate motivations, ie some congress people might vote for something to gain votes while other actually think the bill is good.Takes out and turns calc indicts, consequentialism might be hard but it's not impossible, and the alternative is no action which is worse; and actor spec outweighs since different actors have different ethical standings.3~ Substitutability— only consequentialism explains necessary enablers.Sinnott-Armstrong 92— Walter Sinnott-Armstrong, ~Professor of practical ethics~ 1992, "An Argument for Consequentialism" Dartmouth College Philosophical Perspectives 4~ Weighability— only consequentialism explains degrees of wrongness— you can only explain why breaking a promise to take a dying person to the hospital is worse than breaking a promise to meet for lunch by appealing to consequences.5~ Use epistemic modesty— that's the probability of the framework being true times the magnitude of an impact under it.a. substantively true: maximizes the probability of the most moral value; arguments against a framework mitigate offense under it but that mitigation is contingent, half the debate shouldn't be thrown out just since someone's 1 ahead on fwk.b. clash: discourages debaters from ignoring contention level debate which means we get education about phil and the topic— topical ed outweighs since we only have 2 months for each topic; this is drop the arg.Evaluate consequences – not doing so is morally bankruptDaase and Friesendorf 10 (Daase; Christopher Daase; professor at the Goethe University Frankfurt and head of the program area International Organizations and International Law at the Peace Research Institute Frankfurt; Friesendorf; Cornelius Friesendorf; lecturer at the Goethe University Frankfurt and research fellow at the Peace Research Institute Frankfurt; "Rethinking Security Governance: the problem of unintended consequences"; Routledge; 2010; pp 205-207; http://202.166.170.213:8080/xmlui/bitstream/handle/123456789/1343/Rethinking20Security20Governance20The20problem20of20unintended20consequences20by20Christopher20Daase.pdf?sequence=1andisAllowed=y~~#page=99) ~DTD~ | 1/15/22 |
JanFeb - PTD v5Tournament: 10 - Emory | Round: 4 | Opponent: Marlbo VA | Judge: Alex Berry Advantage 1: Space ColExpansion of PTD key to global space sustainability key to long term colonization efforts.Babcock '19 — Hope M. Babcock, Professor of Law, Georgetown University Law Center, B.A., Smith College, L.L.B., Yale University; (2019; "ARTICLE: THE PUBLIC TRUST DOCTRINE, OUTER SPACE, AND THE GLOBAL COMMONS: TIME TO CALL HOME ET"; University of Michigan Libraries, Nexis Uni; Syracuse University Law Review, Vol. 69; LFS—JCM – Recutish like diff section ISEE) Colonization solves inevitable extinction.Kovic '19 ~Marko; March 2019; co-founder president of the Zurich Institute of Public Affairs Research; "The future of energy," https://osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/aswz9/download~~ PlanStates ought to establish an international public trust obligation towards protection of outer space as a refusal of the appropriation of outer space by private entities.Advantage 2: DebrisCurrent international guidelines are failing – immediate space regulations are key to prevent KesslerBroom 1/12 ~Douglas Broom Henley Business School, 1-12-2022, "As private satellites increase in number, what are the risks of the commercialization of space?," World Economic Forum, https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2022/01/what-are-risks-commercial-exploitation-space/~~/ISEE PTD solves —- nothing else keeps up with private sector growthRauenzahn et al., 20 (Brianna Rauenzahn is a JD candidate at Penn and writer for the regulatory review, Jasmine Wang is a writer for the regulatory review, Jamison Chung, Peter Jacobs, Aaron Kaufman, and Hannah Pugh, 6-6-2020, accessed on 9-12-2021, The Regulatory Review, "Regulating Commercial Space Activity", https://www.theregreview.org/2020/06/06/saturday-seminar-regulating-commercial-space-activity/, HBisevac) Global mitigation and remediation in conjunction are necessary to solve the Kessler effect.Rada Popova 18, European Space Agency Co-Manager, PhD, Faculty of Law @ Universitat zu Koln, postgraduate degree from the Hague Academy for International Law, "The Legal Framework for Space Debris Remediation as a Tool for Sustainability in Outer Space," Aerospace, MDPI, doi:10.3390/aerospace5020055 *adr = active debris removal, sdr = space debris remediation, OOS = on orbit servicing Scenario 1: Solar StormsStable satellites are key to solving grid collapse from solar stormsBoyle, 17 (Rebecca Boyle is an award-winning freelance journalist for The Atlantic and FiveThirtyEight and has twice been anthologized in the Best American Science and Nature Writing, 6-14-2017, accessed on 9-20-2021, NBC News, "How We'll Safeguard Earth From a Solar Storm Catastrophe", https://www.nbcnews.com/mach/space/how-we-ll-safeguard-earth-solar-storm-catastrophe-n760021, HBisevac) AND space weather catastrophes ensure extinctionRosen, 16 (Julia Rosen is a science reporter for the Los Angeles Times with a PhD in geology, accessed on 10-20-2021, Science.org, 7-14-2016, "Here's how the world could end—and what we can do about it", https://www.science.org/content/article/here-s-how-world-could-end-and-what-we-can-do-about-it-rev2, HBisevac) Scenario 2: MiscalcDebris triggers miscalculated war.Peter Dockrill 16. Award-winning science and technology journalist. "Space Junk Accidents Could Trigger Armed Conflict, Study Finds." https://www.sciencealert.com/space-junk-accidents-could-trigger-armed-conflict-expert-warns. ====It goes nuclear.==== FramingUtil Its good —-Its good —-1~ Effective debate necessitates primary focus on material violence— anything else ignores oppression.Dr. Tommy J. Curry 14, ~Dr. Curry is a Prof of Philosophy at Texas AandM University, Ray A. Rothrock Fellow 13'-16' and currently the USC Shoah Foundation 2016-17 A.I. and Manet Schepps Foundation Teaching Fellow, first Black JV National Debate champion (for UMKC) and half of the first all-Black CEDA team to win Pi Kappa Delta~ 2014, "The Cost of a Thing: A Kingian Reformulation of a Living Wage Argument in the 21st Century," http://www.academia.edu/9798210/The_Cost_of_a_Thing_A_Kingian_Reformulation_of_a_Living_Wage_Argument_in_the_21st_Century Brackets in original 2~ Actor spec—a. governments have to aggregate since all collective actions incur tradeoffs that help some and hurt other, means based side constraints freeze action.b. no act omission distinction for governments since policies create permissions and prohibitions so authorizing action cannot be an omission since the state assumes culpability in regulating the public domain, ie voting against something is still acting.c. no intent foresight distinction— governments can't have intent since they're made up of multiple actors with separate motivations, ie some congress people might vote for something to gain votes while other actually think the bill is good.Takes out and turns calc indicts, consequentialism might be hard but it's not impossible, and the alternative is no action which is worse; and actor spec outweighs since different actors have different ethical standings.3~ Substitutability— only consequentialism explains necessary enablers.Sinnott-Armstrong 92— Walter Sinnott-Armstrong, ~Professor of practical ethics~ 1992, "An Argument for Consequentialism" Dartmouth College Philosophical Perspectives 4~ Weighability— only consequentialism explains degrees of wrongness— you can only explain why breaking a promise to take a dying person to the hospital is worse than breaking a promise to meet for lunch by appealing to consequences.5~ Use epistemic modesty— that's the probability of the framework being true times the magnitude of an impact under it.a. substantively true: maximizes the probability of the most moral value; arguments against a framework mitigate offense under it but that mitigation is contingent, half the debate shouldn't be thrown out just since someone's 1 ahead on fwk.b. clash: discourages debaters from ignoring contention level debate which means we get education about phil and the topic— topical ed outweighs since we only have 2 months for each topic; this is drop the arg.Evaluate consequences – not doing so is morally bankruptDaase and Friesendorf 10 (Daase; Christopher Daase; professor at the Goethe University Frankfurt and head of the program area International Organizations and International Law at the Peace Research Institute Frankfurt; Friesendorf; Cornelius Friesendorf; lecturer at the Goethe University Frankfurt and research fellow at the Peace Research Institute Frankfurt; "Rethinking Security Governance: the problem of unintended consequences"; Routledge; 2010; pp 205-207; http://202.166.170.213:8080/xmlui/bitstream/handle/123456789/1343/Rethinking20Security20Governance20The20problem20of20unintended20consequences20by20Christopher20Daase.pdf?sequence=1andisAllowed=y~~#page=99) ~DTD~ | 1/29/22 |
JanFeb - PTD v6Tournament: 12 - Cal rr | Round: 3 | Opponent: Marlbo WR | Judge: Panel Advantage 1: Space ColPrivate colonization is coming now —- but it wont be sustainableRauenzahn et al., 20 (Brianna Rauenzahn is a JD candidate at Penn and writer for the regulatory review, Jasmine Wang is a writer for the regulatory review, Jamison Chung, Peter Jacobs, Aaron Kaufman, and Hannah Pugh, 6-6-2020, accessed on 9-12-2021, The Regulatory Review, "Regulating Commercial Space Activity", https://www.theregreview.org/2020/06/06/saturday-seminar-regulating-commercial-space-activity/, HBisevac) Expansion of PTD key to global space sustainabilityBabcock '19 — Hope M. Babcock, Professor of Law, Georgetown University Law Center, B.A., Smith College, L.L.B., Yale University; (2019; "ARTICLE: THE PUBLIC TRUST DOCTRINE, OUTER SPACE, AND THE GLOBAL COMMONS: TIME TO CALL HOME ET"; University of Michigan Libraries, Nexis Uni; Syracuse University Law Review, Vol. 69; LFS—JCM – Recutish like diff section ISEE) Colonization solves inevitable extinction.Kovic '19 ~Marko; March 2019; co-founder president of the Zurich Institute of Public Affairs Research; "The future of energy," https://osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/aswz9/download~~ PlanStates ought to establish an international public trust obligation towards protection of outer space as a refusal of the appropriation of outer space by private entities.Advantage 2: DebrisCurrent international guidelines are failing – immediate space regulations are key to prevent KesslerBroom 1/12 ~Douglas Broom Henley Business School, 1-12-2022, "As private satellites increase in number, what are the risks of the commercialization of space?," World Economic Forum, https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2022/01/what-are-risks-commercial-exploitation-space/~~/ISEE ====Expanding the PTD over outerspace creates the regulatory framework necessary to regulate space debris==== Global mitigation and remediation in conjunction are necessary to solve the Kessler effect.Rada Popova 18, European Space Agency Co-Manager, PhD, Faculty of Law @ Universitat zu Koln, postgraduate degree from the Hague Academy for International Law, "The Legal Framework for Space Debris Remediation as a Tool for Sustainability in Outer Space," Aerospace, MDPI, doi:10.3390/aerospace5020055 *adr = active debris removal, sdr = space debris remediation, OOS = on orbit servicing Scenario 1: Solar StormsStable satellites are key to solving grid collapse from solar stormsBoyle, 17 (Rebecca Boyle is an award-winning freelance journalist for The Atlantic and FiveThirtyEight and has twice been anthologized in the Best American Science and Nature Writing, 6-14-2017, accessed on 9-20-2021, NBC News, "How We'll Safeguard Earth From a Solar Storm Catastrophe", https://www.nbcnews.com/mach/space/how-we-ll-safeguard-earth-solar-storm-catastrophe-n760021, HBisevac) AND space weather catastrophes ensure extinctionRosen, 16 (Julia Rosen is a science reporter for the Los Angeles Times with a PhD in geology, accessed on 10-20-2021, Science.org, 7-14-2016, "Here's how the world could end—and what we can do about it", https://www.science.org/content/article/here-s-how-world-could-end-and-what-we-can-do-about-it-rev2, HBisevac) Scenario 2: MiscalcDebris triggers miscalculated war.Peter Dockrill 16. Award-winning science and technology journalist. "Space Junk Accidents Could Trigger Armed Conflict, Study Finds." https://www.sciencealert.com/space-junk-accidents-could-trigger-armed-conflict-expert-warns. ====It goes nuclear.==== FramingUtil Its good —-1—-Actor spec—a. governments have to aggregate since all collective actions incur tradeoffs that help some and hurt other, means based side constraints freeze action.b. no act omission distinction for governments since policies create permissions and prohibitions so authorizing action cannot be an omission since the state assumes culpability in regulating the public domain, ie voting against something is still acting.c. no intent foresight distinction— governments can't have intent since they're made up of multiple actors with separate motivations, ie some congress people might vote for something to gain votes while other actually think the bill is good.Takes out and turns calc indicts, consequentialism might be hard but it's not impossible, and the alternative is no action which is worse; and actor spec outweighs since different actors have different ethical standings.2—- Substitutability— only consequentialism explains necessary enablers.Sinnott-Armstrong 92— Walter Sinnott-Armstrong, ~Professor of practical ethics~ 1992, "An Argument for Consequentialism" Dartmouth College Philosophical Perspectives 3—- Weighability— only consequentialism explains degrees of wrongness— you can only explain why breaking a promise to take a dying person to the hospital is worse than breaking a promise to meet for lunch by appealing to consequences.4—- Use epistemic modesty— that's the probability of the framework being true times the magnitude of an impact under it.a. substantively true: maximizes the probability of the most moral value; arguments against a framework mitigate offense under it but that mitigation is contingent, half the debate shouldn't be thrown out just since someone's 1 ahead on fwk.b. clash: discourages debaters from ignoring contention level debate which means we get education about phil and the topic— topical ed outweighs since we only have 2 months for each topic; this is drop the arg.5—-Evaluate consequences – not doing so is morally bankruptDaase and Friesendorf 10 (Daase; Christopher Daase; professor at the Goethe University Frankfurt and head of the program area International Organizations and International Law at the Peace Research Institute Frankfurt; Friesendorf; Cornelius Friesendorf; lecturer at the Goethe University Frankfurt and research fellow at the Peace Research Institute Frankfurt; "Rethinking Security Governance: the problem of unintended consequences"; Routledge; 2010; pp 205-207; http://202.166.170.213:8080/xmlui/bitstream/handle/123456789/1343/Rethinking20Security20Governance20The20problem20of20unintended20consequences20by20Christopher20Daase.pdf?sequence=1andisAllowed=y~~#page=99) ~DTD~ | 2/18/22 |
NovDec - Hauntology v1Tournament: 4 - Applevalley | Round: 1 | Opponent: Troy Independent AP | Judge: Brixz Gonzaba The current formation of labor law is rooted in colonial and class violence. This makes it impossible for these laws to ever be sustainable because they are haunted by specters of the pastRonconi 15~Lucas Ronconi, 11-30-2015, "Colonial history affects labor regulations," World Bank Blogs, https://blogs.worldbank.org/jobs/colonial-history-affects-labor-regulations~~/ISEE Right to strike serves an example of this haunting – making laws in the name of "employer security" rather that what is bestMishel 20 ~Lawrence Mishel 11-18-2020, "Explaining the erosion of private-sector unions: How corporate practices and legal changes have undercut the ability of workers to organize and bargain," Economic Policy Institute, https://www.epi.org/unequalpower/publications/private-sector-unions-corporate-legal-erosion/~~/ISEE Embracing these specters is key to solve for nationalist and authoritarian violence – anything other method justifies erasing all traces that disturb the self-enclosure of the present and turns all impacts.Papastephanou 11 – Associate Professor in the Department of Education at the University of Cyprus (Marianna, "Material Specters: International Conflicts, Disaster Management, and Educational Projects," Educational Theory, Volume 61, Number 1, 2011, pgs. 113-114)DD It outweighs, Authoritarianism causes extinction via nationalist wars, climate, military robots and makes all impacts more probable.Orts '18 ~Eric; June 27; Guardsmark Professor in the Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania; LinkedIn Pulse, "Foreign Affairs: Six Future Scenarios (and a Seventh)," https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/foreign-affairs-six-future-scenarios-seventh-eric-orts~~ Turns all their scenariosSebastian Farquhar 17, leads the Global Priorities Project (GPP) at the Centre for Effective Altruism, et al., 2017, "Existential Risk: Diplomacy and Governance," https://www.fhi.ox.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/Existential-Risks-2017-01-23.pdf ====Thus I affirm A just government ought to recognize an unconditional right of workers to strike as a ghostly revolutionary tatic. ==== The aff is spectrality – only a critical interrogation of the present and the past as singular, totalizing, and complete can prevent the obstruction of possibility.Zembylas 13 – Associate Professor of Educational Theory and Curriculum Studies at the Open University of Cyprus (Michalinos, "Pedagogies of Hauntology In History Education: Learning to Live with the Ghosts of Disappeared Victims of War and Dictatorship," DOI: 10.1111/edth.12010, February 2013)DD ====The role of the ballot is to frontline reconciling with the past and the present ==== Epistemology comes first—-their model of debate risks extinction and turns their framing arguments.Heron 8. Taitu Heron, The Planning Institute of Jamaica. "Globalization, neoliberalism and the exercise of human agency." International Journal of Politics, Culture, and Society 20.1-4 (2008): 85-101.
Our offense turns policy making —- Our ontology is key to policymaking because it's the baseline to the process —- they effect one anotherSin 14 —- post-doctoral researcher, Centre for Research in Higher Education Policies (Cristina Sin, "The policy object: a different perspective on policy enactment in higher education," Proquest, 2/8/14, https://link-springer-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/content/pdf/10.10072Fs10734-014-9721-5.pdf)//lyss Utilitarianism causes genocide.Santos 3 2003, Boaventura de Souza Santos is a Professor of Sociology at the University of Coimbra, "Collective Suicide?", Bad Subjects, Issue ~# 63 , http://www.ces.fe.uc.pt/opiniao/bss/072en.php | 11/5/21 |
NovDec - Hauntology v2Tournament: 5 - Glenbrooks | Round: 5 | Opponent: Harker RM | Judge: Andrew Wixson The current formation of labor law is rooted in colonial and class violence. This makes it impossible for these laws to ever be sustainable because they are haunted by specters of the pastRonconi 15~Lucas Ronconi, 11-30-2015, "Colonial history affects labor regulations," World Bank Blogs, https://blogs.worldbank.org/jobs/colonial-history-affects-labor-regulations~~/ISEE Right to strike serves an example of this haunting – making laws in the name of "employer security" rather that what is bestMishel 20 ~Lawrence Mishel 11-18-2020, "Explaining the erosion of private-sector unions: How corporate practices and legal changes have undercut the ability of workers to organize and bargain," Economic Policy Institute, https://www.epi.org/unequalpower/publications/private-sector-unions-corporate-legal-erosion/~~/ISEE Embracing these specters is key to solve for nationalist and authoritarian violence – anything other method justifies erasing all traces that disturb the self-enclosure of the present and turns all impacts.Papastephanou 11 – Associate Professor in the Department of Education at the University of Cyprus (Marianna, "Material Specters: International Conflicts, Disaster Management, and Educational Projects," Educational Theory, Volume 61, Number 1, 2011, pgs. 113-114)DD Oppressive regimes kill millions of people; preventing them should come firstSebastian Farquhar 17, leads the Global Priorities Project (GPP) at the Centre for Effective Altruism, et al., 2017, "Existential Risk: Diplomacy and Governance," https://www.fhi.ox.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/Existential-Risks-2017-01-23.pdf ====Thus I affirm A just government ought to recognize an unconditional right of workers to strike. The right to strike is a ghostly revolutionary tatic. ==== The aff is spectrality – only a critical interrogation of the present and the past as singular, totalizing, and complete can prevent the obstruction of possibility.Zembylas 13 – Associate Professor of Educational Theory and Curriculum Studies at the Open University of Cyprus (Michalinos, "Pedagogies of Hauntology In History Education: Learning to Live with the Ghosts of Disappeared Victims of War and Dictatorship," DOI: 10.1111/edth.12010, February 2013)DD ====The role of the ballot is to frontline reconciling with the past and the present ==== Epistemology comes first—-their model of debate risks extinction and turns their framing arguments.Heron 8. Taitu Heron, The Planning Institute of Jamaica. "Globalization, neoliberalism and the exercise of human agency." International Journal of Politics, Culture, and Society 20.1-4 (2008): 85-101.
Our offense turns policy making —- Our ontology is key to policymaking because it's the baseline to the process —- they effect one anotherSin 14 —- post-doctoral researcher, Centre for Research in Higher Education Policies (Cristina Sin, "The policy object: a different perspective on policy enactment in higher education," Proquest, 2/8/14, https://link-springer-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/content/pdf/10.10072Fs10734-014-9721-5.pdf)//lyss Utilitarianism causes genocide.Santos 3 2003, Boaventura de Souza Santos is a Professor of Sociology at the University of Coimbra, "Collective Suicide?", Bad Subjects, Issue ~# 63 , http://www.ces.fe.uc.pt/opiniao/bss/072en.php | 11/21/21 |
SeptOct - Hauntology v 1Tournament: 1 - Grapevine | Round: 1 | Opponent: Lexington AR | Judge: Chansey Agler The medical industrial complex is rooted in using disease as a way to reify different modes of colonial and class violence – That make it impossible to imagine medicine as life sustaining because it is haunted by spectres of the past Intellectual property protections on medicines are haunted by the same specters of the ruptured medical industrial complex Embracing these specters is key to solve for nationalist and authoritarian violence – anything other method justifies erasing all traces that disturb the self-enclosure of the present and turns all impacts. It outweighs, Authoritarianism causes extinction via nationalist wars, climate, military robots and makes all impacts more probable. Thus I affirm that the member nations of the World Trade Organization ought to reduce intellectual property protections for medicines as a form of ghostly ethic. The aff is spectrality – only a critical interrogation of the present and the past as singular, totalizing, and complete can prevent the obstruction of possibility. The role of the ballot is to frontline reconciling with the past and the present Epistemology comes first-~--their model of debate risks extinction and turns their framing arguments.
| 9/11/21 |
SeptOct - Hauntology v 2Tournament: 1 - Grapevine | Round: 3 | Opponent: Harrison JC | Judge: Claudia Ribera The medical industrial complex is rooted in using disease as a way to reify different modes of colonial and class violence – That make it impossible to imagine medicine as life sustaining because it is haunted by spectres of the past Intellectual property protections on medicines are haunted by the same specters of the ruptured medical industrial complex Embracing these specters is key to solve for nationalist and authoritarian violence – anything other method justifies erasing all traces that disturb the self-enclosure of the present and turns all impacts. It outweighs, Authoritarianism causes extinction via nationalist wars, climate, military robots and makes all impacts more probable. Thus I affirm that the member nations of the World Trade Organization ought to reduce intellectual property protections for medicines as a form of ghostly ethic. The aff is spectrality – only a critical interrogation of the present and the past as singular, totalizing, and complete can prevent the obstruction of possibility. The role of the ballot is to frontline reconciling with the past and the present Epistemology comes first---their model of debate risks extinction and turns their framing arguments.
Our offense turns policy making --- Our ontology is key to policymaking because it’s the baseline to the process --- they effect one another | 9/11/21 |
SeptOct - Hauntology v 3Tournament: 3 - JWP | Round: 2 | Opponent: Harvard Westlake AT | Judge: Tajaih Robinson ====The medical industrial complex is rooted in using disease as a way to reify different modes of colonial and class violence – That make it impossible to imagine medicine as life sustaining because it is haunted by spectres of the past==== Intellectual property protections on medicines are haunted by the same specters of the ruptured medical industrial complexTWAIL 21 ~Third World Approaches to International Law, 3-23-2021, "On Intellectual Property Rights, Access to Medicines and Vaccine Imperialism," TWAILR, https://twailr.com/on-intellectual-property-rights-access-to-medicines-and-vaccine-imperialism/~~/ISEE Embracing these specters is key to solve for nationalist and authoritarian violence – anything other method justifies erasing all traces that disturb the self-enclosure of the present and turns all impacts.Papastephanou 11 – Associate Professor in the Department of Education at the University of Cyprus (Marianna, "Material Specters: International Conflicts, Disaster Management, and Educational Projects," Educational Theory, Volume 61, Number 1, 2011, pgs. 113-114)DD It outweighs, Authoritarianism causes extinction via nationalist wars, climate, military robots and makes all impacts more probable.Orts '18 ~Eric; June 27; Guardsmark Professor in the Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania; LinkedIn Pulse, "Foreign Affairs: Six Future Scenarios (and a Seventh)," https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/foreign-affairs-six-future-scenarios-seventh-eric-orts~~ Thus I affirm that the member nations of the World Trade Organization ought to reduce intellectual property protections for medicines as a form of ghostly ethic.Street 18 ~Alice Street, School of Social and Political Sciences, University of Edinburgh 12-12-2018, "Ghostly Ethics," Taylor and Francis, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/01459740.2018.1521400~~/ISEE The aff is spectrality – only a critical interrogation of the present and the past as singular, totalizing, and complete can prevent the obstruction of possibility.Zembylas 13 – Associate Professor of Educational Theory and Curriculum Studies at the Open University of Cyprus (Michalinos, "Pedagogies of Hauntology In History Education: Learning to Live with the Ghosts of Disappeared Victims of War and Dictatorship," DOI: 10.1111/edth.12010, February 2013)DD ====The role of the ballot is to frontline reconciling with the past and the present ==== Epistemology comes first—-their model of debate risks extinction and turns their framing arguments.Heron 8. Taitu Heron, The Planning Institute of Jamaica. "Globalization, neoliberalism and the exercise of human agency." International Journal of Politics, Culture, and Society 20.1-4 (2008): 85-101.
Our offense turns policy making —- Our ontology is key to policymaking because it's the baseline to the process —- they effect one anotherSin 14 —- post-doctoral researcher, Centre for Research in Higher Education Policies (Cristina Sin, "The policy object: a different perspective on policy enactment in higher education," Proquest, 2/8/14, https://link-springer-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/content/pdf/10.10072Fs10734-014-9721-5.pdf)//lyss Utilitarianism causes genocide.Santos 3 2003, Boaventura de Souza Santos is a Professor of Sociology at the University of Coimbra, "Collective Suicide?", Bad Subjects, Issue ~# 63 , http://www.ces.fe.uc.pt/opiniao/bss/072en.php | 10/9/21 |
SeptOct - Hauntology v 4Tournament: 3 - JWP | Round: 3 | Opponent: Little Rock Central XJ | Judge: Kelley Kirkpatrick ====The medical industrial complex is rooted in using disease as a way to reify different modes of colonial and class violence – That make it impossible to imagine medicine as life sustaining because it is haunted by spectres of the past==== Intellectual property protections on medicines are haunted by the same specters of the ruptured medical industrial complexTWAIL 21 ~Third World Approaches to International Law, 3-23-2021, "On Intellectual Property Rights, Access to Medicines and Vaccine Imperialism," TWAILR, https://twailr.com/on-intellectual-property-rights-access-to-medicines-and-vaccine-imperialism/~~/ISEE Embracing these specters is key to solve for nationalist and authoritarian violence – anything other method justifies erasing all traces that disturb the self-enclosure of the present and turns all impacts.Papastephanou 11 – Associate Professor in the Department of Education at the University of Cyprus (Marianna, "Material Specters: International Conflicts, Disaster Management, and Educational Projects," Educational Theory, Volume 61, Number 1, 2011, pgs. 113-114)DD It outweighs, Authoritarianism causes mass death via nationalist wars, climate, military robots and makes all impacts more probable.Orts '18 ~Eric; June 27; Guardsmark Professor in the Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania; LinkedIn Pulse, "Foreign Affairs: Six Future Scenarios (and a Seventh)," https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/foreign-affairs-six-future-scenarios-seventh-eric-orts~~ Thus I affirm that the member nations of the World Trade Organization ought to reduce intellectual property protections for medicines as a form of ghostly ethic.Street 18 ~Alice Street, School of Social and Political Sciences, University of Edinburgh 12-12-2018, "Ghostly Ethics," Taylor and Francis, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/01459740.2018.1521400~~/ISEE The aff is spectrality – only a critical interrogation of the present and the past as singular, totalizing, and complete can prevent the obstruction of possibility.Zembylas 13 – Associate Professor of Educational Theory and Curriculum Studies at the Open University of Cyprus (Michalinos, "Pedagogies of Hauntology In History Education: Learning to Live with the Ghosts of Disappeared Victims of War and Dictatorship," DOI: 10.1111/edth.12010, February 2013)DD ====The role of the ballot is to frontline reconciling with the past and the present ==== State and ontology is the only route because critical praxis is actively being censored.Siddique Motala and Kristian D. Stewart '21 Motala is in the Department of Civil Engineering, University of Cape Town. Stewart is at the University of Michigan-Dearborn. https://doi.org/10.1007/s42330-021-00153-7 "Hauntings Across the Divide: Transdisciplinary Activism, Dualisms, and the Ghosts of Racism in Engineering and Humanities Education" lrl Progress is possible through legal change – even if the state has the potential to roll back some policies, antiblackness can be deconstructed via policy changes.Omi and Winant 12 (Michael Omi and Howard Winant, Michael Omi is an American sociologist, Howard Winant is an American sociologist and race theorist, "Resistance is futile?: a response to Feagin and Elias," SYMPOSIUM ON RETHINKING RACIAL FORMATION THEORY, Ethnic and Racial Studies, Volume 36, 2013, https://doi.org/10.1080/01419870.2012.715177, accessed on 7/17/18, AB) | 10/9/21 |
SeptOct - Stock Aff v 1Tournament: 2 - DTA | Round: 2 | Opponent: Stockdale RP | Judge: John Fruge FrameworkI value morality. The standard is maximizing well being.All moral obligations revolve around potential consequences of actionsSam Harris (NYT Bestselling author, BA in phil from Stanford, PhD in neuroscience from UCLA). The Moral Landscape: How Science Can Determine Human Values. 5 October 2010. p3. http://notabenoid.com/book/22437/73890?Orig_page=3 Utilitarianism comes first –approaches can only be ethical when they consider externalities.Chandler '14 Reject the "one percent" doctrine – it's incoherent and makes policymaking impossible. Anything could potentially cause extinction – default to high probability impacts.Meskill 9 — (David Meskill, professor at Colorado School of Mines and PhD from Harvard, "The "One Percent Doctrine" and Environmental Faith," 12-9-2009, http://davidmeskill.blogspot.com/2009/12/one-percent-doctrine-and-environmental.html) Contention 1: Access to Medicine====Status quo pandemic management is plagued with inequality. ==== Historical data proves our thesis– up to 80 of all new patents are not new drugs but old ones.Feldman 2 Robin Feldman 18, May your drug price be evergreen, Journal of Law and the Biosciences, Volume 5, Issue 3, December 2018, Pages 590–647, https://doi.org/10.1093/jlb/lsy022 Arthur J. Goldberg Distinguished Professor of Law, Albert Abramson '54 Distinguished Professor of Law Chair, and Director of the Center for Innovation (Study Notes: Presenting the first comprehensive study of evergreening, this article examines the extent to which evergreening behavior—which can be defined as artificially extending the protection cliff—may contribute to the problem. The author analyses all drugs on the market between 2005 and 2015, combing through 60,000 data points to examine every instance in which a company added a new patent or exclusivity.)sid IP protections are vital to resolve vaccine deficiencies. History disproves all pro patent argumentsKumar, PhD, 7-12-21 Contention 2: Drug PricesIntellectual property protections keep drug prices high.Amin 18 Tahir Amin 6-27-2018 "The problem with high drug prices isn't 'foreign freeloading,' it's the patent system" High drug prices caused by US patent system, not 'foreign freeloaders' (cnbc.com) https://www.cnbc.com/2018/06/25/high-drug-prices-caused-by-us-patent-system.html (co-founder of nonprofit I-MAK.org)Elmer High Drug Prices forces patients to go underground for drugs.Bryant 11 Clifton Bryant 2011 "The Routledge Handbook of Deviant Behaviour" (former professor of sociology at VA Tech)Elmer Counterfeit drugs kill millions.Greenberger 20 Phyllis E. Greenberger 12-3-2020 "Counterfeit Medicines Kill People" https://www.healthywomen.org/health-care-policy/counterfeit-medicines-kill-people/who-suffers-because-of-counterfeit-drugs (HealthWomen's Senior Vice President of Science and Health Policy)Elmer Contention 3: InnovtionThe current pharmaceutical industry is hindering innovation.Mazzucato 18 ~Mariana Mazzucato, 10-17-2018, "Opinion," Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/theworldpost/wp/2018/10/17/pharmaceutical/~~/ISEE While patents first-glance may seem like a good idea, the problem is that many corporations use them to get rid of rivals, functionally monopolizing the market. As a result, medical innovation has slowed down tremendously.Gubby 19 ~Hellen Gubby, professor at the Rotterdam School of Management at Amarus University with a PhD in law, 9-6-2019, "Is the Patent System a Barrier to Inclusive Prosperity? The Biomedical Perspective," Wiley Online Library, https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1758-5899.12730~~/Kankee Pharma Innovation prevents Extinction – checks new diseases.Engelhardt 8, H. Tristram. Innovation and the pharmaceutical industry: critical reflections on the virtues of profit. M and M Scrivener Press, 2008 (doctorate in philosophy (University of Texas at Austin), M.D. (Tulane University), professor of philosophy (Rice University), and professor emeritus at Baylor College of Medicine) | 10/2/21 |
Open Source
| Filename | Date | Uploaded By | Delete |
|---|---|---|---|
9/11/21 | elizabethelliott23@newmanschoolorg |
| |
9/11/21 | elizabethelliott23@newmanschoolorg |
| |
1/29/22 | elizabethelliott23@newmanschoolorg |
| |
2/18/22 | elizabethelliott23@newmanschoolorg |
| |
4/23/22 | elizabethelliott23@newmanschoolorg |
| |
10/2/21 | elizabethelliott23@newmanschoolorg |
| |
10/9/21 | elizabethelliott23@newmanschoolorg |
| |
10/9/21 | elizabethelliott23@newmanschoolorg |
| |
10/12/21 | elizabethelliott23@newmanschoolorg |
| |
11/5/21 | elizabethelliott23@newmanschoolorg |
| |
11/21/21 | elizabethelliott23@newmanschoolorg |
| |
12/18/21 | elizabethelliott23@newmanschoolorg |
| |
12/19/21 | elizabethelliott23@newmanschoolorg |
| |
1/8/22 | elizabethelliott23@newmanschoolorg |
| |
1/13/22 | elizabethelliott23@newmanschoolorg |
| |
1/14/22 | elizabethelliott23@newmanschoolorg |
| |
1/15/22 | elizabethelliott23@newmanschoolorg |
|