| Holy Cross | 1 | Opponent: Kenston EJ | Judge: Oliver Ranner 1ac- pandemic waiver saves most lives especially in developing countries 1nc- a waiver stunts innovation and endangers us 1nr- there would be no incentive to keep innovating 2ar- innovation still exists and people are dying right now which outweighs |
| Holy Cross | 3 | Opponent: Strake Jesuit JK | Judge: Kelvin Yi 1ac- pandemic waiver saves most lives especially in developing countries 1nc- a waiver stunts innovation lacks resources hurts quality and endangers us 1nr- there would be no incentive to keep innovating and no way to keep it safe 2ar- innovation still exists and people are dying right now which outweighs |
| Holy Cross | 6 | Opponent: Vestavia Hills TP | Judge: Dominic Henderson 1ac- pandemic waiver saves most lives especially in developing countries 1nc- a waiver stunts innovation and endangers us It also results in China getting potentially dangerous research 1nr- there would be no incentive to keep innovating and cause China to gain an advantage over us 2ar- innovation still exists and people are dying right now which outweighs it China impact has no link and is improbable |
| Isadore Newman School Invitational | 2 | Opponent: Riverwood LV | Judge: Witt, Kia 1ac- The right to strike has to be guaranteed 1nc- a right to strike would be net bad 2ac- rights come before cost-benefit analysis 1nr- bad for econ 1ar- util is a form of oppression support rights first |
| Isadore Newman School Invitational | 4 | Opponent: Coppell EH | Judge: Ciocca, Daniel 1ac- The right to strike has to be guaranteed 1nc- a right to strike would be net bad a cp for public workers solve better 2ac- rights come before cost-benefit analysis perm 1nr- bad for public sector 1ar- util is a form of oppression support rights first |
| Isadore Newman School Invitational | 5 | Opponent: Little Rock Central MG | Judge: Moon, Ryan 1ac- The right to strike has to be guaranteed 1nc- a right to strike would be net bad 2ac- rights come before cost-benefit analysis 1nr- bad for econ 1ar- util is a form of oppression support rights first |
| LA Districts | 2 | Opponent: Holy Cross ND | Judge: Grayson Lanza 1ac-democracyutil value advocacy journalism leads to echo chambers Objective journalism is key to protecting democracy 1nc- moralitystructural violence value objective journalism hurts minorities advocacy journalism solves better 1nr- reducing structural violence through advocacy journalism 2ar- advocacy journalism is the status quo and hurts democracy if we want change then we need to strengthen trust in the media with objectivity |
| LA Districts | 4 | Opponent: Southside IN | Judge: Anne-Marie Alexander 1ac-democracyutil value advocacy journalism leads to echo chambers Objective journalism is key to protecting democracy 1nc- moralitypragmatism value objective journalism is not possible advocacy journalism allows free expression 1nr- Advocacy journalism is the most practical and presents minimal threat 2ar- advocacy journalism is the status quo and hurts democracy by causing extremism objective truth is absolute and real It can bring people back together |
| LHSSL State | 2 | Opponent: JPG JF | Judge: Stephanie Garrison 1ac- journalism has to prioritize objectivity 1nc- advocacy journalism can be good 1nr- Advocacy journalism is necessary 2ar- good advocacy journalism can exist in aff work because it prioritizes objectivity |
To modify or delete round reports, edit the associated round.